Cover lesson · RE · Year 11 · Advanced

Planning an evaluation: should believers always forgive?

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Religious believers should always forgive. A views pack”, one between two. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 6 min Step 2, unpicking the statement · 10 min Step 3, sorting the arguments · 8 min Step 4, planning the structure · 6 min Step 5, evaluation phrases · 15 min Step 6, writing alone. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice: planning and organising an extended, balanced piece of writing that weighs different views and reaches a justified conclusion. It prepares pupils for the evaluation questions in GCSE Religious Studies, where judgement is worth over a third of the marks. The teachings are real; the four voices are invented. Pupils are not asked about their own experiences of being hurt or forgiving.

What you are doing

The best evaluation answers are planned before they are written. You will take apart the statement, sort the evidence, plan a structure that builds to a judgement, and then write the introduction, one developed paragraph and the conclusion.

Step 1: read the stimulus

Read Part 1, Part 2 and the box on what “evaluate” means.

Step 2: unpick the statement

“Religious believers should always forgive.”

(a) Circle the most important word in the statement. Why does it make the statement hard to agree with completely?

(b) Write a one-sentence definition of forgiveness that you will use in your introduction.

Step 3: sort the arguments

Use Parts 1 and 2. Rate each argument’s strength from 1 (weak) to 3 (strong).

Agree: believers should always forgiveStrengthDisagree: not alwaysStrength

Which argument will you use for the non-religious view?

Step 4: plan the structure

Decide your overall judgement first, then plan so that every paragraph leads towards it.

My judgement in one sentence:

ParagraphMain point and evidence (with a reference)Link to next paragraph
1. Introduction: define, set out the debate, give your line of argument
2. Arguments for the statement
3. Arguments against, including a non-religious view
4. Weighing: which arguments are stronger, and why?
5. Conclusion: a justified judgement(none)

Step 5: evaluation phrases

Match each phrase to its job by writing E (evaluates strength), C (counter-argument) or J (final judgement).

PhraseJob
This is a convincing argument because ...
However, others would argue that ...
On balance, the stronger view is ...
This argument is weakened by the fact that ...
Having considered both sides, I conclude that ...
In contrast, a humanist would say ...

Step 6: write, on your own

Using your plan, write paragraph 1 (introduction), paragraph 3 (against) and paragraph 5 (conclusion): about 200 words in total. Use at least two evaluation phrases and at least one reference to a teaching.

Checklist: ☐ definition ☐ line of argument in introduction ☐ religious and non-religious views ☐ a reference ☐ evaluation phrases ☐ clear judgement that matches my plan.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the stimulus with a partner.
  2. 6 min Step 2: unpick the statement.
  3. 10 min Step 3: sort and rate the arguments.
  4. 8 min Step 4: plan your structure.
  5. 6 min Step 5: match evaluation phrases.
  6. 15 min Step 6: write three paragraphs, on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early