Cover lesson · Science · Year 7 · Beginner

Punctuating a chromatography write-up

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Punctuation

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Chromatography: Gwen’s write-up, her results and a punctuation guide”, one between two. No practical work and no computers. Pupils need a pen and, if you have them, highlighters in 2 colours. Without highlighters, pupils underline instead.

Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 9 min Step 2, sentences and comma splices · 7 min Step 3, lists and colons · 8 min Step 4, apostrophes · 7 min Step 5, brackets, units and question marks · 12 min Step 6, writing a conclusion, alone · 5 min Step 7, partner check · 2 min success criteria. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice: punctuating scientific writing so that a reader can follow it. Step 6 is the best evidence, because pupils punctuate their own writing. It builds towards writing up practical work in GCSE The Sciences (Double Award). The fully punctuated write-up and all answers are on the worked example.

What you are doing

Gwen did a chromatography practical to separate the dyes in 4 felt-tip pens. Her science is good, but her punctuation makes her write-up hard to read. You will fix her sentences one skill at a time, then write and punctuate a better conclusion of your own.

Step 1: read the stimulus

Read section 1 to find out what the practical is about. Then read Gwen’s write-up in section 2, her results in section 3 and the punctuation guide at the bottom.

Step 2: sentences and comma splices

Here is Gwen’s method again.

first i drew a line 2 from the bottom of the paper this is called the base line. i drew it in pencil, pen ink would dissolve in the water. then i put a small dot of each pens ink on the line the dots were 2 cm apart. i poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep, the waters surface was below the base line. i hung the paper from the glass rod with a paper clip i left it for 10 minutes the water moved up the paper, it carried the dye’s with it.

(a) Draw a slash ( / ) where each sentence should end. Circle every letter that should be a capital letter.

(b) Gwen used 5 full stops. How many sentences should her method have? ________

(c) How many times did Gwen write “i” when she needed “I”? ________

(d) Gwen joined 2 sentences with a comma 3 times. This is a comma splice. Fix each one twice: once with a full stop and once with a joining word. Use because, so and and, once each.

Gwen wroteFixed with a full stopFixed with a joining word
i drew it in pencil, pen ink would dissolve in the water
i poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep, the waters surface was below the base line
the water moved up the paper, it carried the dye’s with it

Step 3: lists and colons

(a) Rewrite Gwen’s equipment sentence with a capital letter, a colon, commas between the items and a full stop.

i used this equipment chromatography paper a pencil a ruler 4 felt-tip pens a beaker water a glass rod and a paper clip

(b) Punctuate this sentence in the same way.

the ink in pen 1 contained 3 dyes purple blue and yellow

(c) Which sentence uses the colon correctly? Circle A, B or C, then explain why.

AYou need: a pencil, a ruler and a beaker.
BYou need a pencil, a ruler and a beaker: for this practical.
CYou need 3 things: a pencil, a ruler and a beaker.

Step 4: apostrophes

Write each phrase correctly. Then give the reason, using a letter from the key.

Key: O = one owner (’s) · M = more than one owner (s’) · L = missing letters · P = plural, so no apostrophe

Gwen wroteCorrect versionReason
gwens black pen
each pens ink
the waters surface
in all 4 pens inks
it carried the dye’s with it
the other pens arent pure

(b) Write the last row again in the way a formal science write-up should.

Step 5: brackets, units and question marks

Rewrite each sentence with correct punctuation. Use the punctuation guide to help you.

Gwen wroteYour corrected sentence
pen 2 green made 2 spots blue and yellow (use brackets and a colon)
the water solvent travelled 8.0 cm (use brackets)
the yellow spot travelled 6.1 from the base line
the purple spot moved only 1.5cms
i wonder if the yellow dye is the same in every pen?
would i get the same results with a different solvent

Step 6: write your own conclusion

Mr Prys said Gwen’s conclusion is too short. Write a better one, on your own, in 5 to 7 sentences. Use her results table. Answer these questions in your conclusion:

Your conclusion must include: a capital letter and a full stop in every sentence · a colon before a list · commas in a list · a pair of brackets · an apostrophe for an owner · a unit with every measurement · a question mark. When you finish, highlight each of these in your writing.

Step 7: partner check

Swap sheets with a partner. Tick each point your partner’s conclusion has. Then give back the sheet.

Capital letters and full stopsNo comma splicesColon and commas in a listBracketsApostrophe for an ownerUnits with every numberQuestion mark on a question

Checked by: ____________________

Now copy the sentence your partner thought needed the most work, and write it again correctly.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the stimulus with a partner.
  2. 9 min Step 2: mark the sentences and fix the comma splices.
  3. 7 min Step 3: punctuate the lists and choose the correct colon.
  4. 8 min Step 4: fix the apostrophes.
  5. 7 min Step 5: add brackets, units and question marks.
  6. 12 min Step 6: write and punctuate your own conclusion, on your own.
  7. 5 min Step 7: check a partner’s conclusion and improve one of your sentences.
  8. 2 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early