Cover lesson · English · Year 9 · Intermediate

Questioning the narrator of a short story

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Questioning

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: asking and answering questions in a group. Pupils learn 4 question types (closed, open, probing, follow-up), plan questions about the gaps in a short story, then hot-seat the story’s narrator in groups of 3, where the narrator must stay in role and stay consistent. Pupils finish by summarising what they learned and evaluating one answer. This is Key Stage 3 groundwork for the group and paired discussion in GCSE English Language and Literature Unit 3 (Section 3.2), where pupils build on each other’s ideas and respond to questions. It is practice only, not assessed work. The story is original and invented, so no pupil has read it before.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil. The stimulus sheet “The Last Ferry to Ynys Brith: a short story” (2 pages: the story, then the hot-seat rules), one per group of 3. No computers are needed.

Run: put pupils in groups of 3 (if the numbers do not divide, make one or two groups of 4 in which 2 pupils share the questioner role). 7 min Step 1, the group reads the story aloud, one section each · 5 min Step 2, sort the question types · 8 min Step 3, write 6 questions and prepare the narrator · 2 min set up the hot seat: agree who is Pupil 1, 2 and 3, and read the hot-seat rules on page 2 of the stimulus · 15 min Step 4, three hot-seat rounds of 5 minutes (4 minutes of questions, then 1 minute of observer feedback): call “change” every 5 minutes so roles rotate · 12 min Step 5, summary and evaluation, in silence. Total 49 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The question log (Steps 3 and 4), the observer tally (Step 4) and the summary (Step 5) are the evidence.

Quick checks: Step 2 answers: closed B, E, I; open D, G, K; probing A, F, J; follow-up C, H, L. In the observer tally, a strong round has more open, probing and follow-up questions than closed ones, and at least 2 follow-ups. In Step 5, a secure summary goes beyond the story (it uses what the narrator said in role) and the evaluation gives a reason, not just “it was good”. A model is in the worked example.

What you are doing

You will read an invented short story, The Last Ferry to Ynys Brith. Its narrator hides a lot: why they are going to the island, what happened there when they were 11, and who lit the lamp. You will learn 4 types of question, write questions that dig into those gaps, and then take turns to put the narrator in the hot seat: one of you plays the narrator, one asks the questions and one observes.

Key words:

Step 1: read the story

Read the story aloud in your group, one section each. As you listen, put a small star in the margin of the stimulus sheet next to anything the narrator hints at but does not explain.

The 3 biggest gaps I noticed:

Step 2: sort the questions

(a) These 12 questions were asked in a hot seat, so some of them build on answers the narrator had already given. Write the type of each question: closed, open, probing or follow-up. There are 3 of each.

Question to the narratorType
AWhy did you buy a single ticket when the ferry does not come back until April?
BWhat time does the ferry leave Porth Arian?
CYou said the tin box was your grandfather’s. Why did you have it, and not him?
DWhat was your grandfather like?
EDid you open the brown envelope?
FWhat do you think your mother meant when she said “After everything”?
GTell us about the journey across on the ferry.
HYou say you weren’t scared. So why didn’t you turn round when the ferry left?
IHave you been to Ynys Brith before?
JWhat exactly happened at the white house when you were 11?
KDescribe what you could see as the ferry reached the island.
LYou told us you didn’t want to talk to Idris. What were you afraid he would say?

(b) Closed questions get short answers. Rewrite question E as an open or probing question.

Step 3: plan your questions and prepare the narrator

(a) Write 6 questions for the narrator in the question log below. Include at least 2 open and 2 probing questions, and no more than 1 closed question. Do not copy the questions from Step 2. Leave the last 2 columns empty until you are the questioner in Step 4.

#My questionTypeKey words from the answerFollow-up I asked (if any)
1
2
3
4
5
6

Follow-up starters to use in Step 4: You said... why? · What do you mean by...? · How did that make you feel? · What happened next? · Earlier you said..., but now...

(b) Everyone will be the narrator once. Decide your answers now, in note form, so you can stay consistent. Keep them to yourself.

Gap in the storyMy answer as the narrator
What is in the tin box?
What happened at the white house when I was 11?
Why did I buy a single ticket?
Who do I think lit the lamp?

Step 4: the hot seat (3 rounds of 5 minutes)

Read the hot-seat rules on page 2 of the stimulus sheet. Then run 3 rounds. In each round: 4 minutes of questions, then 1 minute of feedback from the observer. When the teacher calls “change”, move to the next round.

RoundNarratorQuestionerObserver
1Pupil 1Pupil 2Pupil 3
2Pupil 2Pupil 3Pupil 1
3Pupil 3Pupil 1Pupil 2

When you are the questioner: use your question log. Fill in the last 2 columns as you go.

When you are the observer: fill in the tally below. Stay silent until the round ends.

Question typeTallyTotal
Closed
Open
Probing
Follow-up

One follow-up that built on an answer. The narrator said:

So the questioner asked:

Did the narrator stay in role and stay consistent with the story? Give one example.

Step 5: summarise and evaluate (12 minutes)

(a) In about 80 words, summarise what you now know about the narrator. Use the story and the answers you heard in all 3 rounds. Where the rounds gave different answers, say so.

(b) Choose one answer you heard (not your own). Evaluate it in 3 or 4 sentences: was it convincing, did it fit the hints in the story, and what did it reveal? You could use: The most convincing answer was... because... It fitted the hint that... It could have been stronger if...

Step by step

  1. 7 min Step 1: read the story aloud, one section each, and note the gaps.
  2. 5 min Step 2: sort the 12 questions and rewrite question E.
  3. 8 min Step 3: write 6 questions and prepare your narrator answers.
  4. 2 min Choose Pupil 1, 2 and 3 and read the hot-seat rules.
  5. 15 min Step 4: 3 hot-seat rounds of 5 minutes, changing roles each time.
  6. 12 min Step 5: write your summary and your evaluation in silence.

Success criteria

If you finish early