Cover lesson · Design Technology · Year 8 · Intermediate

Reading a case study on iterative design

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: reading in Design Technology. Pupils read a case study about how James Dyson built 5,127 prototypes of a bagless vacuum cleaner, and a short invented blog post by a Year 8 pupil who improved a phone stand 4 times. They skim for the main idea, retrieve facts, make inferences backed by quotations, analyse how the writer uses numbers, structure and language, and compare the purpose and audience of the 2 texts. They finish with a written response of 120 to 150 words. No practical work is needed.

Print: this sheet and the stimulus sheet “5,127 tries: a case study in iterative design”, one of each per pupil. Pupils need a pen and 2 highlighters of different colours (or a pen and a pencil).

Run: 5 min Step 1, skim for the main idea · 8 min Step 2, find the facts · 7 min Step 3, read between the lines · 6 min Step 4, how the writer uses numbers · 6 min Step 5, structure · 6 min Step 6, language · 7 min Step 7, compare the 2 texts · 12 min Step 8, written response, in silence. Total 57 minutes. At the start of Step 8, say “12 minutes, starting now”; give a 2-minute warning.

Collect: this sheet. Pupils may keep the stimulus sheet. The worked example has all the answers and a model response.

What you are doing

Designers rarely get things right first time. They make a prototype, test it, find what is wrong and improve it, again and again. This is called iterative design. Today you will read 2 texts about it: a case study about a famous product (Text A) and a pupil’s blog (Text B). You will work out not just what the writers say, but how and why they say it.

Step 1: skim for the main idea

Skim Text A for 1 minute only: read the title, the headings and the first sentence of each section.

(a) In one sentence of no more than 20 words, what is Text A mainly about?

(b) Under which heading would you look first to find each of these?

I want to findHeading
where the idea for the cyclone came from
when the vacuum cleaner went on sale in the UK
why the old vacuum cleaner lost suction

Now read both texts carefully. In Text A, highlight every number in one colour and every time phrase (such as “In 1993”) in another.

Step 2: find the facts

Answer in a few words, and write the heading where you found it. The first one is done for you.

QuestionAnswerHeading
1. What was wrong with the bag in the old vacuum cleaner?it clogged with dust, so it lost suctionThe problem
2. Where did Dyson see an industrial cyclone?
3. What did that cyclone clean out of the air?
4. Inside a cyclone, what happens to the dust?
5. How many prototypes did Dyson build?
6. About how many years did this take?
7. In which country, and under what name, was the design first sold?
8. What was launched in the UK in 1993?
9. Name 2 features of that 1993 model.

Step 3: read between the lines

An inference is something the writer suggests but does not say directly. Answer each question, then copy a short quotation (in “quotation marks”) that proves it. The first is done for you.

QuestionWhat I inferQuotation as evidence
Did Dyson think the clogging bag was a small problem?No: he thought the whole design was wrong and needed fixing.“Dyson saw this as a design fault, not just a nuisance.”
(a) Why did Dyson keep going after so many failures? Give 2 reasons.
(b) Why might the big British companies not have wanted a vacuum cleaner without a bag?
(c) Why do you think the DC01 had a see-through bin?

Step 4: how the writer uses numbers

(a) The writer gives an exact number of prototypes (5,127) but only says “about 5 years”. Why use an exact number for the prototypes?

(b) Check the writer’s sum with pen and paper: 5 years is about 5 × 52 = ______ weeks, and 5,127 ÷ ______ is roughly ______ prototypes a week. Why does the writer turn the big number into “a week”?

(c) The writer says “5,127 prototypes means 5,126 that were not quite right.” What effect does this have on the reader?

(d) Why do you think the number is in the title?

Step 5: structure

(a) Text A is mostly in chronological (time) order. Copy 3 time phrases that show this.

(b) Text A also follows a problem and solution structure. Fill in the table.

 What it is, in a few wordsHeading
The problem
The idea for a solution
How the solution was made to work
The result

(c) The story ends in 1993, but the writer adds one more section, “What designers can learn”. Why?

Step 6: language

(a) “Build. Test. Learn. Change. Repeat.” Why does the writer use 5 one-word sentences here?

(b) “The dust is flung outwards.” What does the verb flung make you picture? Why is it better than moved?

(c) In the first paragraph, the writer says a failure “is information”. Explain what this means in your own words.

(d) Copy one fact and one opinion from Text A.

Step 7: compare the 2 texts

 Text A: case studyText B: Osian’s blog
Main purpose
Audience
Formal or informal? Give an example
What the writer thinks about failure, with a quotation

(e) Write one way the 2 texts are organised in the same way.

Step 8: your response (12 minutes, on your own)

Question: Is failure an important part of designing? Use evidence from both texts.

Write 120 to 150 words. Use at least one piece of evidence from Text A and one from Text B, and explain what each one shows. End with your own view.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Step 1: skim for the main idea, then read both texts and highlight.
  2. 8 min Step 2: find the 8 facts.
  3. 7 min Step 3: make 3 inferences with quotations.
  4. 6 min Step 4: how the writer uses numbers.
  5. 6 min Step 5: chronological order and problem and solution.
  6. 6 min Step 6: language, fact and opinion.
  7. 7 min Step 7: compare the 2 texts.
  8. 12 min Step 8: write your response, in silence.

Success criteria

If you finish early