Cover lesson · PSE / Well-being · Year 8 · Intermediate
LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data
Name: Class: Date:
Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Ysgol Bro Tawel: how active are our pupils?”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need a pen, a pencil, a ruler and a calculator.
Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 8 min Step 2, reading values · 10 min Step 3, working out percentages · 7 min Step 4, comparing fairly · 12 min Step 5, the misleading newsletter chart · 6 min Step 6, how far the survey can be trusted · 8 min Step 7, writing a fair headline alone. Total 56 minutes.
Collect: this sheet. It is numeracy practice in interpreting data: reading tables and bar charts, turning counts into percentages so groups of different sizes can be compared fairly, spotting a misleading chart and headline, and judging how far a small survey can be trusted. It supports well-being by helping pupils understand the real activity guideline for young people and read health headlines critically. The school and all its figures are invented; the guideline is real. Pupils are not asked about their own activity, fitness or bodies.
Surveys about health are often turned into headlines. Some headlines are fair; others twist the numbers. You will read the results of an invented school survey about physical activity, work out percentages so you can compare Year 7 and Year 9 fairly, find out how a newsletter chart misleads its readers, and then write an accurate headline of your own.
Read the whole stimulus sheet with a partner: the real guideline, how the survey was done, Table A, Chart B, the newsletter (Chart C) and the box about bigger surveys in Wales.
Use Table A and Charts B and C. Write each answer with its unit (pupils or %).
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| a. How many Year 9 pupils returned a diary? | |
| b. How many Year 7 pupils met the 60-minute average? | |
| c. How many pupils altogether did not meet the 60-minute average? | |
| d. Which was the most common main way of being active (Chart B), and how many pupils chose it? | |
| e. How many more pupils chose team sport than swimming (Chart B)? | |
| f. What number does the vertical axis of the newsletter chart (Chart C) start at? |
Year 7 and Year 9 are different sizes, so the counts alone cannot be compared. To find a percentage: number in the group ÷ total in the group × 100. Round to 1 decimal place where needed.
Example: 30 out of 120 pupils is 30 ÷ 120 × 100 = 25%.
| Group | Met the average | Total | % who met it | % who did not meet it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 7 | 72 | 160 | ||
| Year 9 | 50 | 125 | ||
| Both year groups | 122 | 285 |
(a) Show your working for the Year 9 row.
(b) Check: for each row, what should the two percentages add up to? Do yours?
(c) Use Chart B. What percentage of all 285 pupils said walking or cycling to school was their main way of being active? What percentage chose team sport? Show your working.
(a) Sam says: “88 Year 7s did not meet the average, but only 75 Year 9s did not. So Year 7s are less active than Year 9s.” Explain why Sam’s comparison is unfair.
(b) Use your percentages. Which year group had the bigger share of pupils who did not meet the average? By how many percentage points?
(c) Write one fair sentence comparing Year 7 and Year 9. Use both percentages.
(a) Look at the vertical axis of Chart C. Why does starting it at that number change how the bars look?
(b) How far above the bottom of the axis does each bar reach, in percentage points? How many times as tall as the Year 7 bar does the Year 9 bar look?
(c) Work out 60 ÷ 55 and round to 2 decimal places. What does this tell you about the headline’s word “twice”?
(d) The headline also uses the word “lazy”. Give 2 reasons why the survey does not show that Year 9 pupils are lazy.
(e) Redraw the newsletter chart fairly on the grid below. The vertical axis must start at 0. Use 1 square = 5%, so 100% is at the top. Label the scale every 2 squares (0%, 10%, 20% and so on), draw a bar for Year 7 and a bar for Year 9 with a ruler, label both axes and give the chart a title.
Title:
(f) Compare your chart with Chart C. What does your chart show that the newsletter chart hides?
A reporter wants to use this survey to say how active all pupils in Wales are. Give 3 reasons why the survey may not represent all pupils in Wales. Use the “How the survey was done” box.
| Reason | How it could make the results different from all pupils in Wales |
|---|---|
Rewrite the newsletter story so that it is accurate. Write a new headline that does not exaggerate, then 3 sentences of evidence. Each sentence must use at least one percentage from Step 3. In one sentence, say what the survey cannot tell us.
Headline: