Cover lesson · Design Technology · Year 11 · Advanced
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies
Name: Class: Date:
What this practises: reading strategies in Design Technology. Pupils read 3 invented supplier data sheets for plastics that could be used to make a bike mudguard. Each sheet is laid out differently. Pupils skim for gist in a timed 2 minutes, use headings, tables and footnotes to find their way, scan for values to test against a specification, read the small print closely, spot claims that the data do not support, and write a recommendation that cites evidence. GCSE Design and Technology (teaching from 2026) asks pupils to compare and justify the suitability of materials.
Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Choosing a polymer for a bike mudguard: 3 supplier data sheets”, one per pupil. Pupils need a pen and a highlighter if you have them. No calculator is needed.
Run: 3 min read the specification (section 1 of the stimulus) · 6 min Step 1, timed skim and gist · 5 min Step 2, text features · 10 min Step 3, scan against the specification · 8 min Step 4, the small print · 6 min Step 5, claims and reliability · 12 min Step 6, the recommendation, alone. Total 50 minutes.
Step 1 timing: say “Start”, then “Stop, pens down” after exactly 2 minutes. Pupils must not read closely yet: the point is to practise skimming.
Collect: this sheet, for the class teacher to mark against the worked example.
Suppliers publish data sheets so designers can compare materials. But data sheets are also written to sell. Important limits are often hidden in a footnote or small print. Today you will read like a designer: get the gist fast, find exact values, read the small print, and trust the data more than the slogans.
When the cover teacher says “Start”, look only at headings, bold text and the first line of each part. Do not read every word.
| Sheet | Material | Main selling point | Mostly selling, or mostly technical? |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | |||
| B | |||
| C |
Predict: from your skim, which sheet looks most likely to meet the specification? Why?
(a) Where does each sheet give its service temperature? Name the feature (table row, section number, footnote, small print).
(b) Sheet A uses 1 and 2; sheet B uses * and †. What do these symbols tell a reader to do?
(c) Sheet B numbers its sections (2.1, 3.2, 5.3). How does this help an engineer? Why might sheet C not use numbered sections?
Scan for each value. Write the value, then ✓ (meets it), ✗ (fails) or ? (the sheet does not say, or it depends).
| Specification | A: Tarian PP-18 | B: Cragen HD-5 | C: Ffenics ABS-UV |
|---|---|---|---|
| S1 recyclable | |||
| S2 impact at −20 °C | |||
| S3 −20 °C to +60 °C | |||
| S4 UV-stabilised | |||
| S5 density | |||
| S6 black | |||
| S7 price | |||
| S8 order of 330 kg |
(a) Sheet A, footnote 2. Which grade must Beiciau Llwybr order, and what does that do to the price per kg?
(b) Sheet B, note *. The owner wants a red mudguard for a new model. What does the note tell you?
(c) Sheet B, note †. Can the company buy only 330 kg? At about what price per kg? Why is the word typically important?
(d) Sheet C, small print. Why does the warning about scratches matter more for a mudguard than for, say, a television case?
(a) Find one claim on sheet A and one on sheet C that the data on the same sheet do not support. Quote each claim and the data that undermine it.
(b) Who wrote these sheets, and why? Write one question you would ask a supplier before you trusted its sheet.
Write 150 to 200 words to the owner of Beiciau Llwybr. Recommend one material and grade. Quote at least 4 values, saying which sheet (and section or footnote) each comes from. Explain briefly why the other 2 were rejected, and name one thing to check before ordering.