Cover lesson · Maths · Year 11 · Advanced

Reading an unstructured solar roof problem

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: literacy (reading) in Maths. Pupils read an unseen newsletter article that hides a multi-step money problem among facts that do not matter. They skim for the question, scan for numbers, read closely to sort what they need from what they do not, and infer the hidden steps before planning and solving. This is the reading skill behind the unstructured, real-world questions in GCSE Mathematics and Numeracy (Section 3.1, questions set in context).

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Neuadd Cwm Derwen: should we buy solar panels?”, one per pupil, because pupils annotate it. Calculators are allowed from Step 5. Pupils need a pen and a highlighter or coloured pen. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min Step 1, skim (time the first 60 seconds strictly) · 10 min Step 2, scan · 10 min Step 3, close reading · 6 min Step 4, plan · 15 min Step 5, solve and conclude · 4 min Step 6 and success criteria. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet and the annotated stimulus sheet, stapled together. The worked example has a model answer. Key numbers: 9.6 kW of panels make 8,640 kWh a year, worth £1,969.92 a year; the hall pays £10,875; payback is about 5.5 years, so yes, well within 10 years.

What you are doing

Real problems do not come as neat questions. This one is buried in a village newsletter. Before you do any maths, you will read the text in four different ways so that you know exactly what is being asked and which facts matter.

Step 1: skim for gist (60 seconds)

Your teacher will time you. In 60 seconds, skim the article: first lines of paragraphs and bold text only. Then turn it over and answer.

(a) What is the article about, in one sentence?

(b) Which paragraph contains the question you must answer? Write the question in your own words.

Step 2: scan for detail

Scan the article for each number. Write the number with its unit and the paragraph it is in.

FindNumber and unitParagraph
How many panels fit on the roof
The power of one panel
Electricity made each year by 1 kW of panels
The share of electricity the hall will use
Price the hall pays for electricity
Price the hall is paid for electricity it sells
Cost of the installation
Size of the grant

Step 3: close reading

(a) Now read every sentence slowly and annotate the stimulus with Q, N, X and ! (see the table of strategies). Then sort these facts. Tick one box each.

FactNeed itDo not need it
The hall hosted 214 events last year.
The standing charge is 53p a day.
There are 1,000 W in 1 kW.
Each panel measures 1.7 m by 1.1 m.
Gas costs 7p per kWh.
The hall’s savings are £16,800.
Assume prices stay the same.

(b) Explain why the standing charge does not matter, using the words in paragraph 5.

(c) Infer the hidden steps. The article never tells you to do these, but you must. List at least 3. (Hint: look at units, percentages and the word “rest”.)

Step 4: plan before you calculate

Write a numbered plan in words. Each step says what you will work out, not the answer. Aim for 6 to 8 steps.

Step 5: solve and write a conclusion for Ruth

Follow your plan. Show every calculation with units. Then write a conclusion of 2 or 3 sentences that answers both parts of Ruth’s question.

Step 6: reflect

Which reading strategy helped you most today, and why?

Step by step

  1. 5 min Step 1: skim for 60 seconds, then answer.
  2. 10 min Step 2: scan for 8 numbers.
  3. 10 min Step 3: close read, annotate and find the hidden steps.
  4. 6 min Step 4: write a plan in words.
  5. 15 min Step 5: solve and write Ruth’s conclusion.
  6. 4 min Step 6 and tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early