Cover lesson · Science · Year 9 · Intermediate

Reading two articles about a tidal lagoon

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Two articles about Morlyn Bae Gwenith, a tidal lagoon”, one per pupil if possible, because pupils underline it. No computers are needed. Pupils need a pen and a highlighter or pencil.

Run: 7 min Step 1, skimming (time the 2 minutes for each text aloud) · 6 min Step 2, scanning · 10 min Step 3, new words · 9 min Step 4, viewpoints and facts · 5 min Step 5, reliability · 10 min Step 6, summary, alone · 3 min success criteria. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice: using skimming, scanning, word roots, context and inference to read scientific texts. It prepares pupils for reading about renewable resources in GCSE The Sciences Unit 3, Section 3.2.5, and for judging scientific claims in the media. All answers are on the worked example.

What you are doing

A company wants to build a tidal lagoon to make electricity in an invented Welsh bay. You will read two texts about it: a science leaflet and a newspaper report. You will use different reading strategies to understand the science, find the facts and work out what each writer and speaker thinks.

Step 1: skim for the gist

Your teacher will give you 2 minutes for each text. Read only the title, the first sentence of each paragraph and the words in bold. Then write one sentence for each.

TextWhat is it mainly about?What is its purpose? (inform, persuade, report, entertain)
Text A
Text B

Step 2: scan for details

Find each answer as fast as you can. Do not read every word: look for numbers and key words.

QuestionAnswer
1. How long would the lagoon wall be?
2. How many turbines would it have?
3. How many homes could it supply?
4. How many years would the building take?
5. How many wading birds feed on the mud flats in winter?
6. What is the largest tidal range in the bay?

Step 3: work out new words

Find each word in the texts (it is in bold). Work out its meaning using a word root or the sentences around it. Say which strategy you used.

WordStrategy: root or context?Meaning in this text
predictable
sluice
bidirectional
intertidal
sediment
megawatts

Step 4: viewpoints and facts

(a) What does each person think about the lagoon? Copy the words that show it.

PersonWhat they thinkWords that show it
Rhian Owen
Dafydd Morgan
Carys Jenkins

(b) Write F for fact or O for opinion next to each sentence.

SentenceF or O
1. The turbines are bidirectional.
2. This is the most exciting thing to happen to our coast in a century.
3. No fuel is burned while a lagoon generates electricity.
4. It will never let us down.
5. The tidal range in the bay reaches 9 metres.

(c) Rhian says the tide “will never let us down”. Which sentence in Text A suggests this is not the whole truth?

Step 5: which text is more reliable?

(a) Which text would you trust more to explain how a lagoon works? Give 2 reasons.

(b) Several figures in Text B come from the developer. Find 2 of them. Why might they need checking?

Step 6: summarise

In about 60 words and in your own words, explain how a tidal lagoon makes electricity. Then give one advantage and one concern. Do not copy whole sentences from the texts.

Step by step

  1. 7 min Step 1: skim each text for 2 minutes and write its gist and purpose.
  2. 6 min Step 2: scan for 6 details.
  3. 10 min Step 3: work out 6 new words.
  4. 9 min Step 4: viewpoints, facts and opinions.
  5. 5 min Step 5: which text is more reliable?
  6. 10 min Step 6: your summary, on your own.
  7. 3 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early