Cover lesson · RE · Year 8 · Intermediate
LNF: Numeracy → Developing mathematical proficiency → Logical reasoning
Name: Class: Date:
Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Following the Moon or the Sun: how religious calendars work”, one between two. No computers are needed. Calculators are allowed.
Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 7 min Step 2, predicting · 7 min Step 3, checking another way · 8 min Step 4, two Ramadans in one year? · 8 min Step 5, the 33-year cycle · 8 min Step 6, true or false? · 7 min Step 7, writing an explanation alone. Total 50 minutes.
Collect: this sheet. It is numeracy practice in logical reasoning: making predictions, checking them a second way, and building and explaining a mathematical argument. It prepares pupils for GCSE Religious Studies, where they explain religious practices such as fasting accurately. Pupils are not asked about their own beliefs or practices.
Muslims in Wales sometimes fast during Ramadan in winter, and sometimes in the long days of summer. Why? You will use a simple model of the calendar to predict when Ramadan starts, check your predictions, prove some surprising facts and explain the pattern clearly.
Read the whole stimulus sheet. Make sure you understand the model box: every answer today uses it.
(a) How many days shorter is the Islamic year than the solar year in the model?
(b) So each year Ramadan starts that many days earlier. Predict the start date for Years 1 to 4. Use the days-in-each-month table.
| Year | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ramadan starts | 1 March |
Ramadan in Year 0 starts on day 60. The next Ramadan starts 354 days later, on day 60 + 354 = 414. There are only 365 days in Year 0, so day 414 is day 414 − 365 = ...... of Year 1.
(a) Use day numbers to check your Year 1 and Year 2 answers. Do they match?
(b) Explain why “add 354, then take away 365” always gives the same answer as “take away 11”.
(a) Continue the pattern. When does Ramadan start in Year 5? Then add 354 days: when does the next Ramadan start, and in which year?
(b) A pupil says: “Ramadan can start twice in the same solar year.” Use your answer to prove this.
(c) Up to which day number must Ramadan start for a second Ramadan to start in the same solar year? Explain how you know.
(a) Ramadan moves back 11 days each year. About how many years will it take to move back a whole year of 365 days? Show your calculation.
(b) Check the claim: “In 33 solar years there are about 34 Islamic years.” Work out 33 × 365, then divide by 354.
(c) Someone fasts every Ramadan from age 15 to age 50. Will they have fasted in every season? Justify your answer.
Write true or false, and give the calculation or reason that proves it.
| Claim | True or false? Proof |
|---|---|
| 1. “Ramadan in Wales is always in winter.” | |
| 2. “A fast in Llanafon on 21 June is 9 hours longer than a fast on 21 December.” | |
| 3. “Passover moves 11 days earlier every year, like Ramadan.” | |
| 4. “Adding 7 extra months of about 30 days in 19 years makes up for the Moon calendar being about 11 days short each year.” (Hint: work out 19 × 11 and 7 × 30.) |
Write an explanation (about 80 words) for a Year 6 pupil: Why does Ramadan move through the seasons, when Passover and Christmas do not? Use numbers from today, and the words because, so and therefore.