Cover lesson · The Sciences · Year 11 · Advanced

Redrafting a practical write-up

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: proofreading, editing and redrafting in The Sciences. Pupils review an invented pupil’s osmosis write-up against a checklist, correct spelling of scientific terms, replace vague words with precise ones, rewrite the method as numbered steps, fix the results table and redraft the conclusion and evaluation. It builds the independent write-up skills needed for the GCSE The Sciences (Double Award) Unit 7 practical enquiries, where Task 2 is written alone under high control. This is practice only, not NEA work. Pupils must not work on their own Unit 7 enquiry in this lesson, and nothing they write today goes into their NEA folder.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Cai’s osmosis write-up: the first draft”, one per pupil if possible, because pupils mark it up. Pupils need a calculator for Step 5. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min Step 1, read the draft and feedback · 8 min Step 2, spelling · 8 min Step 3, vocabulary · 10 min Step 4, the method · 8 min Step 5, the results · 13 min Step 6, conclusion and evaluation · 3 min success criteria. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The worked example has a corrected version of every part and a model redraft.

What you are doing

Cai did a good practical and got good results, but his write-up loses marks. Your job is to be his editor. You will check his draft against his teacher’s checklist, fix it one part at a time, and then redraft the most important sections. The same checks work on any write-up you do yourself.

Step 1: read and review

Read section 1, then Cai’s draft in section 2, then the checklist in section 3. For each point on the checklist, give Cai a score: 0 (not done), 1 (partly done) or 2 (done well).

Checklist pointScoreThe biggest problem
1. Accuracy
2. Vocabulary
3. Method
4. Results
5. Conclusion
6. Evaluation

Step 2: proofread for spelling

Cai has misspelt 7 different words, and one of them twice. Circle them on the stimulus, then write them here correctly.

Cai wroteCorrect spelling

Step 3: upgrade the vocabulary

Replace each vague phrase with precise scientific wording. Use the word bank in section 4.

Cai wroteBetter scientific wording
sugar water
the potato got bigger
the sugar sucked the water out
left them for a day
one weird result
better scales

(b) Cai says his results were “accurate”. Which word in the word bank describes what his 3 repeats actually show? Why?

Step 4: rewrite the method

Rewrite Cai’s method as numbered steps. Use the equipment and quantities in section 1. Start each step with a command word, such as Cut, Blot, Measure, Record. Include the independent, dependent and control variables somewhere.

Step 5: fix the results

(a) Write better headings for the first and last columns of Cai’s table, with units.

(b) Which result is anomalous? How can you tell?

(c) Recalculate the mean for 0.6 mol/dm3 without the anomaly. Show your working.

(d) Between which two concentrations does the change in mass go from positive to negative? What does that tell you about the potato cells?

Step 6: redraft the conclusion and evaluation

Conclusion (about 80 words): describe the pattern using at least 3 numbers from the table, then explain it using the words osmosis, partially permeable membrane and concentration. Say what concentration the potato cells are likely to be.

Evaluation (about 60 words): name the anomaly and one likely cause, then give two specific improvements and say how each one would help.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Step 1: read the draft and score it against the checklist.
  2. 8 min Step 2: find and correct the spelling mistakes.
  3. 8 min Step 3: upgrade the vocabulary.
  4. 10 min Step 4: rewrite the method as numbered steps.
  5. 8 min Step 5: headings, anomaly and the new mean.
  6. 13 min Step 6: redraft the conclusion and evaluation.
  7. 3 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early