Cover lesson · History · Year 11 · Advanced

Redrafting an essay on the Welsh in Patagonia

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Y Wladfa: the Welsh settlement in Patagonia, 1865”, one per pupil so they can mark it. No computers are needed. Pupils need a pen in a different colour from their writing.

Run: 5 min pupils read the fact file · 10 min Step 2, proofreading · 8 min Step 3, checking the facts · 8 min Step 4, fixing the structure · 15 min Step 5, redrafting alone · 4 min Step 6, reflection. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet and the marked stimulus. It is literacy practice: proofreading, editing and redrafting to improve accuracy, structure and argument. It is practice only, not NEA work, but it builds the redrafting habits that GCSE History enquiries need. The fact file is real history; the draft essay is invented.

What you are doing

Strong history essays are rarely right first time. You will improve a weak first draft written by an invented pupil: correct the spelling, punctuation and facts, sort out the structure, and then rewrite part of it so that it answers the question with a clear judgement.

Step 1: read the fact file

Read Part 1 of the stimulus carefully. Then read the question and the draft in Part 2 once, without marking it.

Step 2: proofread

Use the codes in the box on the stimulus. Mark every mistake you can find in the draft, writing the code above it in a different colour. Then record 8 of them here.

SentenceCodeMistakeCorrection

Step 3: check the facts

(a) Sentence 1 contains 3 factual mistakes. Rewrite the sentence correctly, as two sentences.

(b) Sentence 5 is vague. Rewrite it so that it says what the Blue Books were, when they were published and why they mattered.

(c) Sentence 11 is accurate, but why does it not help to answer this question?

Step 4: fix the structure

The draft is one long block and ends without a judgement. Plan a better structure. Write the sentence numbers you would keep (improved) in each paragraph, and one new idea to add.

ParagraphSentences to useNew idea or evidence to add
1. Introduction with a clear answer to “how far”
2. Protecting the language and way of life
3. Other reasons: poverty, land, adventure
4. Conclusion: which reason mattered most and why

Why is sentence 12 a weak conclusion?

Step 5: redraft, on your own

Rewrite paragraph 2 and the conclusion (about 180 words in total). Use formal language, correct facts, at least one specific piece of evidence from the fact file, and a clear judgement that answers “how far”.

Step 6: reflect

Name the two most important improvements you made, and one thing you will check in your own writing from now on.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the fact file and the draft.
  2. 10 min Step 2: proofread with codes.
  3. 8 min Step 3: check and correct the facts.
  4. 8 min Step 4: plan a better structure.
  5. 15 min Step 5: redraft paragraph 2 and the conclusion, on your own.
  6. 4 min Step 6: reflect.

Success criteria

If you finish early