Cover lesson · English · Year 11 · Advanced

Researching a talk with reliable sources

DCF: Producing → Sourcing, searching and planning digital content

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: the individually researched oral presentation in GCSE English Language and Literature. For pupils who began the course in September 2025 this is Unit 2: Belonging, Task B, where pupils research a theme linked to Belonging (cynefin, community and citizenship) and “consider and comment on the reliability and validity of sources and evidence”. For pupils who began in September 2026 or later, WJEC’s amendments moved the individually researched presentation to Unit 5 Task B (Double Award). Practice only, not NEA work. The town, topic and sources are invented and are not linked to any text pupils are studying. Nobody presents or records anything today.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Stay or go? A research pack on belonging in Aberderwen”, one between two. Calculators help in Step 3. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min pupils read the brief and the search results page · 8 min Step 1, searching · 14 min Step 2, the reliability grid · 10 min Step 3, testing the claims · 8 min Step 4, references · 10 min Step 5, one side of notes. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet.

What you are doing

You are preparing a 4 to 6 minute researched talk: Stay or go? What makes young people feel they belong in a valleys town, and why do some of them leave? You have one search and six sources. Some are strong, some are weak, and some are wrong. You will search more efficiently, judge every source, test the claims against the strongest evidence, change your conclusion where the evidence demands it, reference your sources, and plan the talk on one side of notes.

Key words:

Search techniques

TechniqueExampleWhat it does
Quotation marks"young people"Finds that exact phrase.
ORbelonging OR cynefinFinds pages with either word. Type OR in capitals.
Minus sign-homesRemoves pages that contain that word. No space after the minus.
site:site:gov.walesOnly results from that website, or that kind of site, such as site:ac.uk for universities.
filetype:filetype:pdfOnly that type of file. Research reports are often PDFs.
after:after:2024Only pages updated after that date (Google).

Most search engines already look for all of your words (AND). Some, such as Bing, also accept AND and NOT typed in capitals.

Step 1: search efficiently

(a) Look only at the search results page. Which two results would you open first, and which two would you skip? Give a reason for each from the label, the web address, the date or the snippet.

(b) Write three better searches. Each must use at least one technique from the table, and you must say what it will find or remove. One must include the Welsh words cynefin or perthyn (to belong).

 SearchWhat it will find or remove
1
2
3

(c) Name one limitation of the search engine itself: why is the order of results not the same as the order of reliability?

Step 2: judge every source

Read Sources A to F in full. Score each one for reliability out of 5, and justify the score with evidence from the source itself.

  Who made it, and why? Evidence and date /5 Will you use it? How?
A
B
C
D
E
F

Step 3: test the claims

(a) Source C’s headline says “Most young people plan to quit Aberderwen”. Check it against Table 1 in Source B. Is the headline valid? What would be accurate?

(b) Source F says the population “has HALVED”. Use the census figures in Source B. By what percentage did the population actually fall, to one decimal place? What would it have been in 2021 if it had halved?

(c) In Source E, “four of those nine have come back”. What percentage is that, to one decimal place? Give two reasons why this is weaker evidence than it sounds, and compare it with what Source B says about coming back.

(d) Before researching, you believed: “Young people leave Aberderwen because they don’t feel they belong there.” Rewrite this conclusion so that it fits the evidence, using at least two figures. Then name one question that none of the six sources can answer.

Step 4: reference your sources

Choose the three sources you would use in your talk. Write a reference for each in this format:

Author or organisation (year) Title. Website or publisher. Available at: web address (Accessed: date you viewed it).

For each source, write the sentence you would say aloud to bring it into your talk. The listener should be able to tell how far to trust it, without you giving a lecture on reliability. For example: “A survey carried out last year by an independent research charity found …”

Step 5: plan the talk on one side of notes

In a real researched presentation you may use up to one side of A4 of short bullet points or cue cards: statistics, facts, examples and quotations. Never a script: reading from notes loses marks. Plan a 4 to 6 minute talk: an opening that hooks the listener, three main points (each with a figure or quotation and the letter of its source), one view that disagrees with yours, and a closing line.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the brief and the search results page.
  2. 8 min Step 1: choose results, write three better searches, name a limitation.
  3. 14 min Step 2: read all six sources and complete the grid.
  4. 10 min Step 3: test the claims and rewrite your conclusion. Show your working.
  5. 8 min Step 4: three references and three spoken sentences.
  6. 10 min Step 5: one side of bullet-point notes.

Success criteria

If you finish early