Cover lesson · Maths · Year 9 · Advanced
DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content
Name: Class: Date:
What this practises: digital competence in Maths. Pupils evaluate a draft set of revision slides against its audience and purpose, give feedback that helps the author improve, redesign one slide and justify their choices. It also practises literacy: in Step 3 pupils proofread the slide text for spelling, punctuation, grammar and notation, and in Step 5 they rewrite it accurately. Their marked-up text and redrafted slide show how well they proofread, edit and improve writing.
Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Ffion’s Pythagoras revision slides: first draft”, one between two, in colour if possible. Pupils need a calculator, a ruler and a coloured pen for corrections. All the correct maths is in section 1 of the stimulus, so you do not need to know Pythagoras’ theorem.
Run: 5 min read stimulus sections 1 and 2 · 10 min Step 1, check the maths · 8 min Step 2, judge the design · 10 min Step 3, proofread · 6 min Step 4, feedback · 12 min Step 5, redesign slide 3 · 6 min Step 6, justify. Total 57 minutes.
Collect: this sheet. The worked example has every answer. Checkpoints: slide 3 should give c = 13 cm (25 + 144 = 169, √169 = 13); slide 4 should give 8 cm (100 − 36 = 64, √64 = 8); the slide text has 17 spelling, punctuation, grammar and notation errors.
Ffion has made revision slides for Year 8. Her teacher has asked you to review them before they go online. A good reviewer checks three things: is the maths right, does the design work for the audience, and is the writing accurate? Then they give feedback the author can act on, and show what better looks like.
(a) Redo slide 3 correctly. Show every step.
(b) Redo slide 4 correctly. Show every step.
(c) Without doing any calculation, how could Ffion have known her slide 4 answer of 11.66190379 cm was wrong?
(d) Find two more maths mistakes on slide 2 (one in the words and one in the diagram), and one more in the last sentence of slide 4.
Use Mr Rowlands’ checklist (section 2 of the stimulus). For each slide, give the checklist number of its biggest design problem and explain why it matters for a Year 8 pupil reading on a phone.
| Slide | Checklist number | Why it matters for this audience |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||
| 2 | ||
| 3 | ||
| 4 |
(b) Find one thing Ffion has done well.
Here is the text from all 4 slides. There are 17 errors in spelling, punctuation, grammar and maths notation (ignore the maths mistakes you found in Step 1). Circle each error in a coloured pen and write the correction above it. Count as you go.
Slide 1: Pythagoras Therom · Every thing you need to no!!!
Slide 2: pythagoras theorem works on all triangles. a2 + b2 = c2 were c is the longest side, called the hypotenuese. the other two sides is a and b.
Slide 3: Example 1: find the hypotenuse. The two short sides are 5cm and 12cm. 5 + 12 = 17 so c = 17cm
Slide 4: … Its really easy, just remember too always add the squares, then you’re answer is always the hypotenuese, and thats it!
Errors I found: ______ out of 17.
(b) The last sentence of slide 4 is one long sentence joined with commas. Rewrite it as 2 or 3 correct sentences, and change it so the maths is right too.
Write 3 comments, as if you were adding them to the slides online. Make them kind, specific and useful.
| Type | Slide | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Praise (what works and why) | ||
| Question (to make her think) | ||
| Suggestion (one clear change) |
Draw your improved slide 3 in the box. It must have: a short title, a correctly labelled right-angled triangle with the right-angle mark, the correct working with a² notation, the answer with its unit, and no more than 30 words. Write a note beside it saying what colours and fonts you would use.
My colours and fonts:
Explain 3 changes you made in Step 5 and why each one makes the slide better for Year 8 pupils revising on a phone. Use the word “because” in each.