Cover lesson · Design Technology · Year 10 · Advanced

Running a design review meeting: Bocs Bwyd

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Collaborative talk

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: speaking in Design Technology. Pupils hold a formal design review meeting for an invented reusable lunch box. Each pupil takes a role (Chair, Client voice, Engineer or Maker, Sustainability lead, Minute-taker), weighs 3 invented proposals against a brief, lists options and reaches an agreed decision with reasons. In round 2 the roles swap and a problem card changes the brief. Designers review ideas with clients and users like this, and GCSE Design and Technology (teaching from 2026) asks pupils to act on the views of others and clients.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Bocs Bwyd: design review pack”, one per group. Set up: groups of 5 around a table. A group of 4 combines Chair and Minute-taker. Give out roles quickly, for example by alphabetical order of first names. Tell pupils not to read section 5 (the problem card) until round 2.

Run: 3 min set up groups and roles · 4 min Step 1, meeting phrases · 7 min Step 2, read the pack and prepare, alone · 20 min Step 3, the meeting · 10 min Step 4, swap roles and round 2 · 6 min Step 5, reflection, alone. Total 50 minutes.

Signal: raise your hand and say “Pause”; pupils stop talking and raise a hand too. Give a warning at 5 minutes and at 1 minute before the end of each meeting. To swap roles, say “Rotate”: each pupil passes their role to the person on their left.

Collect: the Minute-taker’s sheet from each group (the minutes for both rounds are the main evidence) and every pupil’s sheet. Walk round during the meetings and note any pupil who does not speak.

What you are doing

You are a design team. Cegin Gymunedol Aberfelen needs 500 lunch boxes and has 3 proposals. In 20 minutes your group must agree which one to recommend, or how to change one, and record the decision with reasons. A good meeting is not a debate that one person wins: every role is heard, several options are compared, and the group reaches a decision that it can explain to the client.

Step 1: meeting phrases

Read the examples. Add one phrase of your own in each row, suitable for a formal meeting.

PurposeExampleMy own phrase
Inviting“We haven’t heard from the Sustainability lead yet. What do you think?”
Building“To add to that point, the test results also show …”
Challenging“I see why you like B, but how does it meet the £4.50 budget?”
Offering an option“What if we kept A but changed the clips?”
Summarising“So far we agree that …, but we still disagree about …”

Which purpose is this? “Can I check: are we saying the budget matters more than the logo?”

Step 2: prepare (alone)

Read sections 1 to 4 of the pack and your own role card. Then fill in your notes.

My role in round 1: ____________________   My top priority: ____________________

ProposalBest evidence for it (from the pack)Best evidence against it
A: Clip
B: Dur
C: Plyg

My 1-minute opening view (key words only):

A question I will ask another role, and an option I could suggest:

Step 3: the meeting (20 minutes)

The Chair follows the agenda in section 4 of the pack. The Minute-taker fills in the minutes below. Everyone else notes 2 things they said and which phrase type they used.

Minutes: round 1

Present and roles:

Item 3: how each proposal meets the brief (problems found):

Item 4: options considered (at least 3):

Decision:

Reasons (at least 2, with evidence from the pack):

Disagreement recorded:

Actions (who, what, by when):

If you are not the Minute-taker: 2 things I said, and the phrase type:

Step 4: round 2 (10 minutes)

When the cover teacher says “Rotate”, pass your role to the person on your left. Read the problem card in section 5 together. You have 8 minutes to agree a revised recommendation. Does your round 1 decision still work? What are the options now?

My role in round 2: ____________________

Minutes: round 2

Options considered:

Revised recommendation and reasons:

What we will tell the client honestly about anything we cannot meet:

Step 5: reflection (alone)

(a) Describe one moment when you helped the group move forward. What exactly did you say?

(b) How did your group reach its decision: full agreement, a compromise, or a vote? Was it fair to every role? Explain.

(c) Which role was harder for you, and why? What will you do differently in your next formal meeting?

Step by step

  1. 3 min Get into groups and take a role.
  2. 4 min Step 1: meeting phrases.
  3. 7 min Step 2: read the pack and prepare, alone.
  4. 20 min Step 3: hold the meeting and take minutes.
  5. 10 min Step 4: rotate roles, read the problem card and hold round 2.
  6. 6 min Step 5: reflect on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early