Cover lesson · Maths · Year 9 · Intermediate

Testing claims on the Caerwenlli Maths board

LNF: Numeracy → Developing mathematical proficiency → Logical reasoning

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: numeracy in Maths. Pupils decide whether claims are always, sometimes or never true, back each decision with examples and counterexamples, and write short proofs using algebra and angle facts. They learn why trying a few examples is not a proof. This builds towards the reasoning and proof marks in GCSE Mathematics and Numeracy (Section 3.1, AO3).

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “The Caerwenlli Maths club claims board”, one between two. No calculators. No computers are needed. Pupils may talk in pairs during Step 2.

Run: 6 min read the stimulus and do Step 1 · 12 min Step 2, sorting the claims · 12 min Step 3, proofs · 10 min Step 4, Lowri’s claim · 6 min Step 5 · 4 min success criteria. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The worked example has every answer. Checkpoints: claims 1, 3 and 6 are always true; 5 is never true; 2, 4, 7 and 8 are sometimes true. Lowri’s claim fails at n = 40, because the answer is 1,681 = 41 × 41.

What you are doing

Eight pupils have pinned claims to the Maths club board. Your job is to judge each one and to prove your judgement. A good mathematician never says “it worked for my examples, so it is always true”.

Step 1: the language of proof

QuestionAnswer
What is the difference between an example and a proof?
How many counterexamples do you need to show a claim is not always true?
Write any even number using n. Write any odd number using n.
Write 3 consecutive whole numbers, starting with n.

Step 2: always, sometimes or never?

For each claim, write A (always), S (sometimes) or N (never). Give your evidence: an example, a counterexample, or a reason.

No.A, S or NEvidence
1
2
3
5
6
7
8

Claim 4 has its own step later.

Step 3: prove it

(a) Prove claim 1. Use the tools in section 4. Fill in the gaps, then finish the argument.

Let the two odd numbers be 2a + 1 and 2b + 1. Their sum is (2a + 1) + (2b + 1) = ______________ = 2( ____________ ) This is 2 × a whole number, so ________________________________

(b) Prove claim 3 in the same way. Start with n + (n + 1) + (n + 2).

(c) Prove claim 6. Sketch a quadrilateral and draw one diagonal. Explain in full sentences.

(d) Explain why claim 5 is never true. Use the angle sum of a triangle.

Step 4: Lowri’s claim

(a) Check one of Lowri’s results: work out n2 + n + 41 when n = 5.

(b) Now work out n2 + n + 41 when n = 40. Show your working.

(c) Work out 41 × 41. What does this tell you about your answer to (b)?

(d) Is claim 4 always, sometimes or never true? Write a reply to Lowri explaining what was wrong with her argument. Be kind and be precise.

Step 5: your own conjecture

Write your own conjecture about even and odd numbers, for example about multiplying them. Test it with 3 examples, then say whether you can prove it.

Step by step

  1. 6 min Read the stimulus. Step 1: the language of proof.
  2. 12 min Step 2: sort 7 claims with evidence.
  3. 12 min Step 3: prove claims 1, 3 and 6, and explain claim 5.
  4. 10 min Step 4: test Lowri’s claim and reply to her.
  5. 6 min Step 5: your own conjecture.
  6. 4 min Tick the success criteria you have met.

Success criteria

If you finish early