Cover lesson · History · Year 9 · Advanced

Verifying Historical Photographs and Captions from the South Wales Coalfield

DCF: Citizenship → Digital rights, licensing and ownership · LNF: Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: pupils verify viral social media history posts against archive catalogue cards from the South Wales coalfield (1910 to 1936), identify provenance errors and Creative Commons licence breaches, and write accurate museum captions with full attribution lines.

Board: open the supply teacher presentation (/cover-lesson-resources/presentations/verifying-historical-photographs-and-captions-from-the-south-wales-coalfield.html) for board slides, built-in timers and spoken script.

Print: this worksheet (one per pupil) and the stimulus sheet “Coalfield Archive Cards and Viral Posts” (one between two). No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min settling starter · 5 min key terms and Creative Commons codes · 10 min Step 1 provenance audit · 10 min Step 2 copyright and licensing · 12 min Step 3 museum captions · 5 min Step 4 historian’s judgement and self-check · 3 min plenary check. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this named worksheet at the end of the lesson. Keep stimulus sheets for reuse.

Quick checks: Post A is from November 1910 (Cambrian Combine Lockout soup queue, AI-colourised from a black-and-white negative); Post B is from 14 May 1921 (surface lamp-room apprentices aged 14 and 15, breaking BY and ND by cropping the watermark); Post C is from August 1926 (breaks NC and BY by selling £14.99 mugs without credit); Post D is from October 1936 (Aberdare hunger marchers protesting against the Means Test, in copyright until 2062, breaking BY).

What you are doing

Popular social media accounts often repost historical photographs without checking where they came from, cropping off archive watermarks, inventing dramatic captions, or running black-and-white negatives through AI colourisation software without telling viewers. You will compare 4 viral posts with official Welsh archive catalogue cards from 1910 to 1936, check which copyright and Creative Commons rules were broken, and write museum-standard captions.

Key words

Step 1: Audit the 4 viral posts against the archive catalogue cards

Read Sections 1 and 2 of the stimulus sheet. Complete the table below to show what the official archive record proves and what each viral post gets wrong. Row A has been started for you.

Post & Archive Ref True date, place and event on Archive Card Historical or visual errors in the viral post Evidence from the Archive Card that proves it
Post A
CWM-1910-042
November 1910, Tonypandy Central Hall, Cambrian Combine Lockout Claims it is an original colour photo of colliers cheering a pay rise.
Post B
CWM-1921-118
Post C
CWM-1926-209
Post D
CWM-1936-305

Step 2: Check copyright duration and Creative Commons licence rules

(a) In the UK, copyright on a photograph normally lasts for the photographer’s lifetime plus 70 years after the year they died. Calculate the copyright expiry year for these two photographers:

1. Arthur Lewis (Card 1, died in 1938): 1938 + 70 = __________ → Is this photo in copyright in 2026? (Yes / No): __________

2. Gareth Thomas (Card 4, died in 1992): 1992 + 70 = __________ → Is this photo in copyright in 2026? (Yes / No): __________

(b) Complete the licensing audit table below using Section 2 and Section 3 of the stimulus sheet.

Post Official licence on Archive Card Which specific rule or code was broken? What the account holder must change or stop doing
Post A Public Domain
Post B
Post C
Post D

Step 3: Write two accurate museum captions with full attribution lines

Choose two of the four photographs (for example Card 2 and Card 4, or Card 1 and Card 3). Using the formula in Section 4 of the stimulus sheet, write a museum display caption for each. Include:

Museum Caption 1 (Archive Reference: ________________________)

Historical explanation:

TASL Attribution line:

Museum Caption 2 (Archive Reference: ________________________)

Historical explanation:

TASL Attribution line:

Step 4: Historian’s judgement on digital alterations and provenance

Answer in 4 to 5 full sentences: Why is it dangerous for historians and the public when social media accounts crop off archive watermarks and post AI-colourised photographs without attribution? Use the terms provenance, derivative and attribution in your answer.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Settling starter: compare Post A with Archive Card 1.
  2. 5 min Read the Creative Commons and copyright table on the stimulus sheet.
  3. 10 min Step 1: audit all 4 viral posts against the official archive cards.
  4. 10 min Step 2: calculate copyright expiry dates and identify licence breaches.
  5. 12 min Step 3: write 2 complete museum captions with TASL attribution lines.
  6. 5 min Step 4: write your historian’s judgement and check the success criteria.
  7. 3 min Plenary: check key answers before handing in your sheet.

Success criteria

If you finish early