Cover lesson · History · Year 9 · Advanced

Why Welsh speakers rose while the percentage fell

LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Welsh speakers in the census, 1901 to 2021”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need a pen, a ruler and a calculator.

Run: 5 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 8 min Step 2, reading the table and graph · 10 min Step 3, working out changes · 10 min Step 4, the 1901 to 1911 puzzle · 7 min Step 5, the 1991 to 2001 rise · 7 min Step 6, percentage points or per cent? · 10 min Step 7, a written judgement alone. Total 57 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is numeracy practice in interpreting data: reading values from a real table and line graph, working out changes in a number and in a percentage, finding a whole from a part and a percentage, telling percentage points apart from per cent, and using both measures to reach a supported judgement. It supports History by asking pupils to explain change over time using the context notes on the stimulus sheet. All the census figures are real (rounded to the nearest thousand); the answers to every calculation are in the worked example.

What you are doing

In 1911 more people in Wales could speak Welsh than in any census before or since, yet the percentage who could speak Welsh had fallen. How can both be true? You will read real census figures from 1901 to 2021, work out how the number and the percentage changed, solve the 1911 puzzle by working out the size of the whole population, and then use both measures to judge the claim “The Welsh language was strongest in 1911.”

Step 1: read the stimulus

Read the whole stimulus sheet with a partner: the background, the table, the graph, the context notes and the reminder box about percentages.

Step 2: read the values

Use the table unless the question says to use the graph. Write each answer with its unit (people, % or a year).

QuestionAnswer
a. How many people aged 3 and over could speak Welsh in 1931?
b. Use the graph only. About what percentage could speak Welsh in 1981? Give your answer to the nearest whole number. Then check it against the table.
c. Use the graph only. In which census year did the percentage first drop below 30%?
d. In which census was the number of Welsh speakers highest? What was it?
e. In which census was the percentage of Welsh speakers highest? What was it?
f. List the 3 censuses when the number of speakers went up compared with the census before.
g. In which of those 3 censuses did the percentage go up as well?

Step 3: work out the changes

For each pair of censuses, work out the change in the number of speakers and the change in the percentage, in percentage points. Always take the later figure minus the earlier figure, and write + for a rise and − for a fall. The first row is done for you.

FromToChange in number of speakersChange in percentage (percentage points)
20112021538,000 − 562,000 = −24,00017.8 − 19.0 = −1.2
19011911
19111921
19811991
19912001
20012011

(a) In which 2 of your pairs did the number go up while the percentage went down?

(b) 1911 to 1921 and 1901 to 1911 both show the same change in percentage points. What is it? Did the number change in the same way in both decades?

Step 4: the 1901 to 1911 puzzle

The percentage is the number of Welsh speakers out of everyone aged 3 and over. If you know the number and the percentage, you can work out that whole population: number ÷ percentage × 100 (see the reminder box on the stimulus sheet). Round your answers to the nearest thousand.

CensusWelsh speakersPercentageEveryone aged 3 and overPeople aged 3 and over who could not speak Welsh
1901930,00049.9%
1911977,00043.5%

(a) Show your working for the 1911 row.

(b) By how many people did the population aged 3 and over grow from 1901 to 1911? By how many did the Welsh speakers grow? (Use your rounded figures.)

(c) Work out the percentage change from 1901 to 1911 for the Welsh speakers and for the whole population aged 3 and over. Use: change ÷ starting value × 100, and round to 1 decimal place.

(d) Now solve the puzzle. In 2 or 3 sentences, explain why the number of Welsh speakers rose but the percentage fell. Use your answers to (b) and (c) and the context notes about the coal industry.

Step 5: the 1991 to 2001 rise

From 1991 to 2001, both the number and the percentage went up, for the first time in the table.

(a) Use number ÷ percentage × 100 to work out everyone aged 3 and over in 1991 and in 2001, to the nearest thousand.

(b) Work out the percentage change from 1991 to 2001 for the Welsh speakers and for the whole population aged 3 and over, to 1 decimal place. Which grew faster? What does that do to the percentage?

(c) Use the context notes. Give 2 possible reasons for the rise, and 1 reason why a historian should be careful about saying Welsh “grew” by this much.

Step 6: percentage points or per cent?

From 1901 to 2021, the percentage who could speak Welsh fell from 49.9% to 17.8%.

(a) What is the fall in percentage points?

(b) What is the percentage change in the percentage? Work out: fall in percentage points ÷ 49.9 × 100, to 1 decimal place.

(c) What is the percentage change in the number of speakers from 1901 to 2021, to 1 decimal place?

(d) Two headlines describe the same figures. For each one, say whether it is accurate and why. Rewrite any headline that is wrong.

HeadlineAccurate? Why?
A: “Welsh speakers down by 32% since 1901”
B: “Share of people who speak Welsh has fallen by almost two thirds since 1901”

My rewritten headline:

Step 7: write a judgement, on your own

“The Welsh language was strongest in 1911.” How far do you agree? Write a paragraph of about 6 to 8 sentences.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the stimulus with a partner.
  2. 8 min Step 2: read values from the table and the graph.
  3. 10 min Step 3: work out changes in the number and in percentage points.
  4. 10 min Step 4: solve the 1901 to 1911 puzzle.
  5. 7 min Step 5: explain the 1991 to 2001 rise.
  6. 7 min Step 6: tell percentage points apart from per cent.
  7. 10 min Step 7: write your judgement, on your own.

Success criteria

If you finish early