Cover lesson · Geography · Year 9 · Intermediate

Writing a flood management decision for Pontgwenlas

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Managing flooding in Pontgwenlas: three options”, one between two. No computers are needed. Pupils need a pen and a highlighter or coloured pencil.

Run: 6 min pupils read the stimulus in pairs · 12 min Step 2, the sustainability grid · 6 min Step 3, the plan · 20 min Step 4, writing alone and in silence · 6 min Step 5, checking and improving. Total 50 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. It is literacy practice: planning and organising a piece of decision writing in linked paragraphs. It prepares pupils for GCSE Geography Unit 4: Sustainable Solutions, section 4.2.5, where they must reject options and justify a decision against the economic, social and environmental pillars. There is no single right answer: any option can score well if the writing is well organised and uses the evidence.

What you are doing

Pontgwenlas keeps flooding. The council can afford only one of three options. You will sort the evidence, plan your writing, and then write a clear, organised report that rejects two options and justifies the third. The skill you are practising is organising writing: every paragraph has one job, and connectives link the paragraphs together.

Step 1: read the stimulus

Read the fact file, the table of options and what people say. Key words:

Step 2: sustainability grid

For each option, write one advantage (+) and one disadvantage (−) for each pillar. Use a figure from the stimulus wherever you can.

PillarA: Flood wallsB: Slow the flowC: Protect homes and move
Economic+

−
+

−
+

−
Social+

−
+

−
+

−
Environmental+

−
+

−
+

−

Step 3: plan your writing

Choose the option you think is best. Then fill in the plan. Each box is one paragraph. Write notes, not sentences.

Paragraph and its jobMy notes (option, reasons, figures)
1. Reject one option, with 2 reasons
2. Reject the other option, with 2 reasons
3. Justify my choice against all 3 pillars
4. Conclusion: admit the main weakness and say why it is still the best choice

Connective bank. Use at least 4 different ones, and start paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 with a linking word or phrase.

AddingContrastingCause and effectConcluding
furthermore, in addition, alsohowever, whereas, although, on the other handas a result, therefore, because, this means thatoverall, for these reasons, on balance

Step 4: write your decision

Write about 250 words, in 4 paragraphs, following your plan. Begin: “The council should choose Option ... to manage flooding in Pontgwenlas.”

Step 5: check and improve

Now improve one sentence. Copy it here, then rewrite it so it is clearer or links better to the paragraph before.

Step by step

  1. 6 min Read the stimulus with a partner.
  2. 12 min Step 2: fill the sustainability grid, with figures.
  3. 6 min Step 3: choose an option and plan 4 paragraphs.
  4. 20 min Step 4: write your decision alone, in silence.
  5. 6 min Step 5: check against the list and improve one sentence.

Success criteria

If you finish early