Cover lesson · Business · Year 10 · Intermediate
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context
Name: Class: Date:
What this practises: extended evaluative writing for GCSE Business (Made for Wales). Assessment objective AO3 asks pupils to “analyse, evaluate, or make judgements on business issues”, and both examinations include extended answers based on a business situation. Pupils plan and write a 9-mark “recommend” answer: they gather evidence, build developed points with connectives, mark a weak answer, plan, then write on their own. This is a literacy lesson: the skill is organising a written argument.
Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “Caffi’r Bont: two ways to grow”, one between two. Pupils need two different coloured highlighters or pencils. No computers are needed.
Run: 6 min read the case study in pairs · 8 min Step 2, the evidence grid · 8 min Step 3, build chains of reasoning · 8 min Step 4, mark Dylan’s answer · 8 min Step 5, plan · 17 min Step 6, write the answer alone and in silence, then check it. Total 55 minutes.
Collect: this sheet. The worked example has a model answer. Either option can earn full marks if it is justified; the model chooses Option B.
Siân owns a café and wants to grow. She can open a second café or buy a catering van. In the exam you will often be asked to recommend a choice like this. The marks go to answers that are organised: a clear recommendation, developed points about both options, figures from the case study, and a conclusion that weighs things up. Today you will plan and write one of these answers step by step.
Read sections 1 to 6 with your partner. Highlight evidence about Option A in one colour and Option B in another. Draw a box around each of Siân’s 4 aims.
For each aim, write the evidence from the case study, with a figure if there is one. Then put a tick (helps the aim) or a cross (works against the aim).
| Siân’s aim | Option A: second café | ✓ or ✗ | Option B: catering van | ✓ or ✗ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Known across the valley, more profit | ||||
| 2. Borrow no more than £10,000 | ||||
| 3. Keep weekends for family | ||||
| 4. Welsh cakes baked in her kitchen |
A simple point gets 1 mark. A developed point explains what the point leads to. Use the connectives in the box to turn each simple point into a chain of 2 or 3 linked sentences. Use a figure from the case study in each chain.
Cause and effect: because · so · as a result · this means that · therefore
Contrast: however · whereas · in contrast · on the other hand
Adding: furthermore · also · in addition
Example. Simple point: The café has a manager. Developed: Option A has a full-time manager, so Siân would not need to work there. However, the manager costs £26,000 a year, which means the café makes only £4,000 extra profit in year 1.
(a) Simple point: The van needs less borrowing.
(b) Simple point: The van works at weekends.
(c) Simple point: Customers would visit a café in Aberbryn.
Dylan wrote this answer to the question in section 6 of the case study.
“I think Siân should open the second café because she will get more customers and make more money. The van is also good because it can go to festivals. But the weather might be bad and then nobody will come. The café costs £30,000 which is a lot. Overall the café is best because it is better.”
(a) Use the practice mark scheme in section 7 of the case study. Which level is Dylan’s answer, and what mark would you give out of 9?
Level: Mark: out of 9
(b) Dylan says the café will “make more money”. What does the case study say about profit in year 1? Why does this weaken his answer?
(c) Write down 3 things Dylan should add or change to reach Level 3.
Choose Option A or Option B. There is no single right answer: the marks are for how well you justify it. Fill in the plan in notes, not full sentences.
| Part | What it does | Your notes |
|---|---|---|
| Opening sentence | Say which option you recommend and give the main reason in a few words. | |
| Paragraph 1 | Your strongest reason, developed, with a figure and a link to an aim. | |
| Paragraph 2 | A second reason, developed, with a figure. Compare with the other option. | |
| Paragraph 3 | The biggest drawback of your choice. Be honest about it. | |
| Conclusion | Weigh it up: why your choice is still better. Say what the decision depends on. |
On your own, in silence. Write your answer to the question in section 6 of the case study in 200 to 250 words. Follow your plan. Leave 2 minutes at the end to check it against the list below.
Check: ☐ I say clearly which option I recommend. ☐ I write about both options. ☐ I use at least 3 figures from the case study. ☐ I link points to Siân’s aims. ☐ I use at least 4 different connectives. ☐ My conclusion says what the decision depends on.