Cover lesson · Food and Nutrition · Year 11 · Advanced

Writing conclusions for a scone investigation

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

Name: Class: Date:

Cover teacher: you need no subject knowledge

What this practises: writing clear, linked sentences in a conclusion. GCSE Food and Nutrition (Made for Wales) Unit 2: Food Investigation asks pupils to draw conclusions and evaluate their results (2.3.3), and AO3, analyse and evaluate, is 20% of the qualification. Pupils sort connectives, combine short notes into complex sentences, fix a draft full of comma splices and repetition, then write a conclusion that links results, science and hypothesis. It uses an invented pupil’s investigation. This is practice only, not NEA work. Pupils must not work on their own Unit 2 investigation today. No cooking today.

Print: this sheet, one per pupil, and the stimulus sheet “How much baking powder makes the best scone? The results”, one between two. Pupils need three different coloured highlighters or pencils. No computers are needed.

Run: 5 min read the results in pairs · 8 min Step 2, sort the connectives · 10 min Step 3, combine the notes · 8 min Step 4, fix Rhys’s draft · 14 min Step 5, write the conclusion alone and in silence · 10 min Step 6, check and improve. Total 55 minutes.

Collect: this sheet. The worked example has model sentences and a model conclusion. The key idea: the hypothesis is only partly supported, because the tallest scones were not the best.

What you are doing

Rhys has finished his food investigation, but his notes are a list of short, choppy facts. A good conclusion links ideas: it says what happened, why it happened, and what that means for the hypothesis. The words that do the linking are connectives, and the way you build sentences is called syntax. Today you will turn Rhys’s notes into a conclusion an examiner would enjoy reading.

Step 1: read the results

Read sections 1 to 5 with your partner. Answer out loud: Which scones were tallest? Which were liked most? Why did the 18 g scones taste soapy?

Step 2: sort the connectives

Write each connective in the right column.

because · however · furthermore · therefore · whereas · as a result · although · in addition · this shows that · consequently · in contrast · similarly · for example · so · this is supported by

Cause and effectContrastAdding or comparingPointing to evidence

Write one sentence about Rhys’s results that uses a contrast connective.

Step 3: combine the notes

Join each set of notes into one sentence using the connective given. You may change the order of the words, but keep the facts and the figures.

 NotesUseYour sentence
1The 0 g scones rose 18 mm. The 12 g scones rose 38 mm.whereas
2The 18 g scones were the tallest. The tasters did not like them.although (start the sentence with it)
3Baking powder gives off carbon dioxide. The scones rise.as a result
4The 12 g scones had the best texture. They had the highest overall score.not only … but also
5The height went up 11 mm from 0 g to 6 g. It went up only 3 mm from 12 g to 18 g.however
6The 18 g scones tasted soapy. Too much alkali was left in them.because
7The dough was heated. The gas bubbles expanded.when (start the sentence with it)
8The hypothesis was partly correct. The scones got taller. They did not all get better.because … but

Punctuation tip: “however” and “therefore” cannot join two sentences with just a comma. Use a full stop or a semicolon before them and a comma after: …to 6 g. However, it…

Step 4: fix Rhys’s draft

Rhys tried to write his conclusion. Find the problems: underline 2 comma splices (two sentences joined by only a comma), circle every repeated “and then”, and box the sentence that gets the hypothesis wrong. Then rewrite the paragraph below.

“The scones with more baking powder rose more, the 18 g ones were the tallest. The 0 g ones were flat and then the 6 g ones were a bit better and then the 12 g ones were the best and then the 18 g ones tasted soapy. This is because of carbon dioxide. My hypothesis was right, the tallest scones were the best.”

Step 5: write the conclusion

On your own, in silence. Write Rhys’s conclusion in 150 to 200 words. Use this order:

  1. Answer the question in one sentence.
  2. Describe the height results with figures. Say how the pattern changes.
  3. Explain the rise with the science, using cause and effect connectives.
  4. Describe the taste results with figures, using a contrast connective.
  5. Say whether the hypothesis is supported, partly supported or not supported, and why.

Step 6: check and improve

(a) Highlight your connectives in three colours: cause and effect, contrast, and adding or evidence. Write how many of each you used.

Cause and effect:     Contrast:     Adding or evidence:  

(b) Underline the first word of every sentence. If 3 or more sentences start the same way, rewrite one so that it starts differently, for example with “When”, “Although” or “As a result”.

(c) Copy your weakest sentence, then write an improved version underneath.

Step by step

  1. 5 min Read the results and the science.
  2. 8 min Sort the 15 connectives and write one contrast sentence.
  3. 10 min Combine the 8 sets of notes into single sentences.
  4. 8 min Find the problems in Rhys’s draft and rewrite it.
  5. 14 min Write the conclusion on your own.
  6. 10 min Check your connectives and sentence openings, then improve.

Success criteria

If you finish early