Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · Geography · Year 11
5 minutesFlood risk decision modelling
Pont-rhaf has £2.0 million to spend on flood protection and 4 ways to spend it. You will build a model that turns flood chances into money, compare the options fairly, add the things money cannot measure, and test whether your answer survives a wetter future.
While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet, then read sections 1 to 3 of the briefing sheet and answer Step 1.
Starter question: (a) A Zone 1 resident says “That was our 1-in-10-year flood, so we’re safe for nine years.” What is wrong with this? (b) The chance of no flood in a year is 0.9. What is the chance Zone 1 floods at least once in the next 10 years, as a percentage?
Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key words · Geography · Year 11
2 minutesYour brief: one formula, 4 options, 1 recommendation
You will work out today’s expected flood damage, run the same model for Options A, B, C and B+C, score them in a weighted matrix for 3 stakeholders, double the chances to test the model, then write a recommendation and an evaluation. The model is the tool, not the answer.
Annual chance
A 1-in-10-year flood has a 10% chance (0.1) in any one year. 1-in-50 is 0.02, 1-in-200 is 0.005. Two can happen in 2 years running.
Expected annual damage (EAD)
What flooding costs on average each year, over a very long time. EAD = annual chance × number of homes × damage per flooded home.
Benefit to cost ratio (BCR)
50-year benefit ÷ 50-year cost. Above 1 means the option prevents more damage than it costs.
Slide 3 of 7 · Steps 2 and 3: build and run the model · Geography · Year 11
22 minutesStep 2 & Step 3: today’s damage, then each option
Step 2 (7 min): EAD for each zone today and the total. Which zone costs the town most each year, even though it has the fewest homes? Why?
| Zone | Homes | Annual chance | Damage per home (£) | EAD today (£ per year) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 40 | 0.1 | 30,000 | 0.1 × 40 × 30,000 = 120,000 |
Step 3 (15 min): use the new chances and damage figures from section 4 of the briefing. 3a: EAD per zone and total for A, B, C and B+C. 3b: annual benefit = EAD if we do nothing − EAD with the option; 50-year benefit = annual benefit × 50; 50-year cost = up-front cost + (yearly upkeep × 50); BCR = 50-year benefit ÷ 50-year cost, to 2 decimal places. Tick whether the up-front cost is within £2.0m.
Model row, Option A (wall): Zone 1 0.01 × 40 × 30,000 = 12,000 · Zone 2 0.01 × 60 × 30,000 = 18,000 · Zone 3 unchanged 15,000 · total 45,000. Annual benefit 171,000 − 45,000 = 126,000; 50-year benefit 6,300,000; 50-year cost 4,000,000 + 1,250,000 = 5,250,000; BCR 1.20; within budget: No.
Slide 4 of 7 · Steps 4 and 5: the weighted matrix and a wetter future · Geography · Year 11
18 minutesStep 4 & Step 5: add what money cannot measure, then test the model
Step 4 (10 min): score value for money from your BCR and “homes still flooded in a 1-in-50-year flood” using the rules in section 5 of the briefing. Copy the other 3 scores from section 5. Weighted total = each score × its weight (section 6), added up.
| Option | Homes flooded in a 1-in-50 | Value | Homes | Environment | How soon | Community | Finance officer | Residents | Ecologist |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A (wall) | 0 | 2 | 5 | 1 | 3 | 2 | 26 | 36 | 23 |
Residents on the wall: 2×1 + 5×5 + 1×1 + 3×2 + 2×1 = 36.
Step 5 (8 min): section 7 of the briefing. Double every annual chance (Zone 1 today goes from 0.1 to 0.2) and run the model again for doing nothing, Option A and Option B+C. Costs do not change. Does the scenario change which is better value, whether the wall is worth building, or whether it can be afforded?
Slide 5 of 7 · Step 6: recommend and evaluate · Geography · Year 11
7 minutesStep 6: recommend one option, then judge your own model
Paragraph 1: recommend one option to the council. Use at least 3 pieces of evidence from Steps 3 to 5 (BCR, matrix totals, budget, the doubled-chances test) and say who will be disappointed and why.
Paragraph 2: name 3 ways this model is simpler than reality. For each one, say whether it makes the options look better or worse than they really are.
Model opening: “I recommend B+C: natural flood management in Upper Cwm Rhaf together with flood doors and resilience measures for the 40 Zone 1 homes. It costs £1.68m, inside the £2.0m budget. It cuts expected flood damage from £171,000 to £52,500 a year …”
Slide 6 of 7 · Self and partner check · Geography · Year 11
2 minutesCheck your work against the success criteria
Read your recommendation again as if you were the council. Tick each criterion you have met, then correct 1 thing.
- I can explain what an annual chance of flooding means and work out the chance of at least one flood over several years.
- I built the model correctly: expected annual damage for every zone and option, with totals I can show working for.
- I used the model to compare options fairly, using benefit, 50-year cost, benefit to cost ratio and the budget.
- I combined money and non-money criteria in a weighted matrix and showed how different priorities change the answer.
- I tested my recommendation against a what-if scenario and judged the model’s assumptions instead of treating its output as fact.
Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary review · Geography · Year 11
2 minutesQuick-check answers before handing in
Check your main figures before your worksheets are collected.
| Question | Correct answer |
|---|---|
| What is the total expected annual damage if the council does nothing? | £171,000 a year (Zone 1 120,000 + Zone 2 36,000 + Zone 3 15,000). |
| Which option has the best BCR, and which option cannot be afforded? | C has the best BCR, 4.77. A, the wall, costs £4.0m up front against a £2.0m budget. |
| When every chance doubles, what happens to the BCRs of A and B+C? | They double: A 1.20 → 2.40, B+C 2.09 → 4.19. The order does not change. |