Supply teacher deck · Geography · Year 11

Flood Risk Decision Modelling

Slide 1 of 7
05:00

Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · Geography · Year 11

5 minutes

Flood risk decision modelling

Pont-rhaf has £2.0 million to spend on flood protection and 4 ways to spend it. You will build a model that turns flood chances into money, compare the options fairly, add the things money cannot measure, and test whether your answer survives a wetter future.

While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet, then read sections 1 to 3 of the briefing sheet and answer Step 1.

Starter question: (a) A Zone 1 resident says “That was our 1-in-10-year flood, so we’re safe for nine years.” What is wrong with this? (b) The chance of no flood in a year is 0.9. What is the chance Zone 1 floods at least once in the next 10 years, as a percentage?

DCF: Data and computational thinking → Problem-solving and modelling No computers needed · calculator on every desk

Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key words · Geography · Year 11

2 minutes

Your brief: one formula, 4 options, 1 recommendation

You will work out today’s expected flood damage, run the same model for Options A, B, C and B+C, score them in a weighted matrix for 3 stakeholders, double the chances to test the model, then write a recommendation and an evaluation. The model is the tool, not the answer.

Annual chance

A 1-in-10-year flood has a 10% chance (0.1) in any one year. 1-in-50 is 0.02, 1-in-200 is 0.005. Two can happen in 2 years running.

Expected annual damage (EAD)

What flooding costs on average each year, over a very long time. EAD = annual chance × number of homes × damage per flooded home.

Benefit to cost ratio (BCR)

50-year benefit ÷ 50-year cost. Above 1 means the option prevents more damage than it costs.

LNF: Numeracy → Developing mathematical proficiency → Strategic competence Only the inputs change; the formula stays the same

Slide 3 of 7 · Steps 2 and 3: build and run the model · Geography · Year 11

22 minutes

Step 2 & Step 3: today’s damage, then each option

Step 2 (7 min): EAD for each zone today and the total. Which zone costs the town most each year, even though it has the fewest homes? Why?

Zone Homes Annual chance Damage per home (£) EAD today (£ per year)
1 40 0.1 30,000 0.1 × 40 × 30,000 = 120,000

Step 3 (15 min): use the new chances and damage figures from section 4 of the briefing. 3a: EAD per zone and total for A, B, C and B+C. 3b: annual benefit = EAD if we do nothing − EAD with the option; 50-year benefit = annual benefit × 50; 50-year cost = up-front cost + (yearly upkeep × 50); BCR = 50-year benefit ÷ 50-year cost, to 2 decimal places. Tick whether the up-front cost is within £2.0m.

Model row, Option A (wall): Zone 1 0.01 × 40 × 30,000 = 12,000 · Zone 2 0.01 × 60 × 30,000 = 18,000 · Zone 3 unchanged 15,000 · total 45,000. Annual benefit 171,000 − 45,000 = 126,000; 50-year benefit 6,300,000; 50-year cost 4,000,000 + 1,250,000 = 5,250,000; BCR 1.20; within budget: No.

Steps 2 and 3 on your worksheet · 22 minutes Benefits are measured against doing nothing

Slide 4 of 7 · Steps 4 and 5: the weighted matrix and a wetter future · Geography · Year 11

18 minutes

Step 4 & Step 5: add what money cannot measure, then test the model

Step 4 (10 min): score value for money from your BCR and “homes still flooded in a 1-in-50-year flood” using the rules in section 5 of the briefing. Copy the other 3 scores from section 5. Weighted total = each score × its weight (section 6), added up.

Option Homes flooded in a 1-in-50 Value Homes Environment How soon Community Finance officer Residents Ecologist
A (wall) 0 2 5 1 3 2 26 36 23

Residents on the wall: 2×1 + 5×5 + 1×1 + 3×2 + 2×1 = 36.

Step 5 (8 min): section 7 of the briefing. Double every annual chance (Zone 1 today goes from 0.1 to 0.2) and run the model again for doing nothing, Option A and Option B+C. Costs do not change. Does the scenario change which is better value, whether the wall is worth building, or whether it can be afforded?

Steps 4 and 5 on your worksheet · 18 minutes The budget is a hard limit, not another score

Slide 5 of 7 · Step 6: recommend and evaluate · Geography · Year 11

7 minutes

Step 6: recommend one option, then judge your own model

Paragraph 1: recommend one option to the council. Use at least 3 pieces of evidence from Steps 3 to 5 (BCR, matrix totals, budget, the doubled-chances test) and say who will be disappointed and why.

Paragraph 2: name 3 ways this model is simpler than reality. For each one, say whether it makes the options look better or worse than they really are.

Model opening: “I recommend B+C: natural flood management in Upper Cwm Rhaf together with flood doors and resilience measures for the 40 Zone 1 homes. It costs £1.68m, inside the £2.0m budget. It cuts expected flood damage from £171,000 to £52,500 a year …”

Step 6 on your worksheet · 7 minutes, in silence Any option is fine if your own figures support it

Slide 6 of 7 · Self and partner check · Geography · Year 11

2 minutes

Check your work against the success criteria

Read your recommendation again as if you were the council. Tick each criterion you have met, then correct 1 thing.

  • I can explain what an annual chance of flooding means and work out the chance of at least one flood over several years.
  • I built the model correctly: expected annual damage for every zone and option, with totals I can show working for.
  • I used the model to compare options fairly, using benefit, 50-year cost, benefit to cost ratio and the budget.
  • I combined money and non-money criteria in a weighted matrix and showed how different priorities change the answer.
  • I tested my recommendation against a what-if scenario and judged the model’s assumptions instead of treating its output as fact.
2 minutes · self check Finished early? Do the tasks under “If you finish early”

Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary review · Geography · Year 11

2 minutes

Quick-check answers before handing in

Check your main figures before your worksheets are collected.

Question Correct answer
What is the total expected annual damage if the council does nothing? £171,000 a year (Zone 1 120,000 + Zone 2 36,000 + Zone 3 15,000).
Which option has the best BCR, and which option cannot be afforded? C has the best BCR, 4.77. A, the wall, costs £4.0m up front against a £2.0m budget.
When every chance doubles, what happens to the BCRs of A and B+C? They double: A 1.20 → 2.40, B+C 2.09 → 4.19. The order does not change.
Check your name and class are on your worksheet Leave briefing sheets neat on the desk