Supply teacher deck · Maths · Year 9

Interpreting Box Plots and Averages for Broadband Speeds in Wales

Slide 1 of 7
05:00

Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · Maths · Year 9

5 minutes

Interpreting Box Plots and Averages for Broadband Speeds in Wales

A county council surveyed broadband download speeds (in Mbps) across 15 homes in a rural village (Cwm Hafod) and 15 homes in a nearby market town (Trefelin). A broadband company claims Cwm Hafod gets an average of 37 Mbps.

While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet, then look at the Cwm Hafod data in section 1 of the stimulus sheet.

Starter question: Out of the 15 homes surveyed in Cwm Hafod, how many actually receive 37 Mbps or faster, and why is the mean 37 Mbps?

LNF: Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy No computers needed · work on your sheet

Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key words · Maths · Year 9

5 minutes

Five-number summaries, quartiles and box plots

When data has an outlier, a five-number summary and box plot show the true distribution far more clearly than the mean and range alone.

Positions for n = 15

Order from smallest to largest:
Lower quartile (Q1): 4th value
Median (Q2): 8th value
Upper quartile (Q3): 12th value

Range vs IQR

Range: Max − Min (100% of data).
Interquartile range (IQR): Q3 − Q1 (middle 50% of data).

Why IQR matters

The IQR ignores the top 25% and bottom 25%, so a single outlier cannot distort it.

LNF: Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy Check section 2 of the stimulus sheet for the quartile position rules

Slide 3 of 7 · Step 1 · Calculate the five-number summaries

10 minutes

Step 1: Order Cwm Hafod’s speeds and complete the summary table

First put Cwm Hafod’s 15 speeds in order from smallest to largest. Then find the five-number summary, range, interquartile range (IQR) and mean for both Cwm Hafod and Trefelin.

Statistic How to find it (n = 15 ordered values) Cwm Hafod (first 2 done)
Minimum & Lower quartile (Q1) 1st value & 4th value Min = 6 Mbps · Q1 = 10 Mbps
Median (Q2) & Upper quartile (Q3) 8th value & 12th value Work out on your sheet
Maximum, Range & IQR 15th value · Max − Min · Q3 − Q1 Work out on your sheet
LNF: Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy Include units (Mbps) and check that you have all 15 values

Slide 4 of 7 · Step 2 · Read the box plots and explain the outlier

10 minutes

Step 2: Why the IQR is fairer than the range here

Look at the box plots in section 3 of your stimulus sheet and complete Step 2 on your worksheet.

Compare the two spreads for Cwm Hafod:

• Total Range (all 15 homes) = 310 − 6 = 304 Mbps
• Range of the 14 homes without Hendre Farm = 33 − 6 = 27 Mbps
• Interquartile range (IQR) (middle 50% of homes) = 26 − 10 = 16 Mbps

LNF: Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy Quote the numbers for both Range and IQR in your explanation

Slide 5 of 7 · Steps 3 and 4 · Test 4 claims and write the comparison report

12 minutes

Steps 3 & 4: Test the 4 claims and compare the distributions

In Step 3, judge whether each of the 4 claims is True or False / Misleading and prove your verdict with figures. In Step 4, write a structured comparison for the county council.

What every secure comparison of two distributions must include
1. Compare an average in context: compare the medians (18 Mbps in Cwm Hafod vs 56 Mbps in Trefelin) and explain what that means for typical households.
2. Compare the spread in context: compare the interquartile ranges (16 Mbps in Cwm Hafod vs 24 Mbps in Trefelin) and explain which place has more consistent speeds across its middle 50%.
3. Explain the outlier: explain why Cwm Hafod’s mean (37 Mbps) and range (304 Mbps) should not be used.
LNF: Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy Every comparison sentence needs a statistic name, both numbers, and the real-world meaning

Slide 6 of 7 · Self-check and extension

5 minutes

Check your comparison report against the GCSE standard

Read your Step 4 paragraph carefully. In GCSE Mathematics and Numeracy, saying “Trefelin’s median is higher” without quoting the numbers and context does not earn full marks.

Checklist for Step 4:

• Did I quote 18 Mbps vs 56 Mbps for the medians?
• Did I quote 16 Mbps vs 24 Mbps for the interquartile ranges?
• Did I mention Hendre Farm’s 310 Mbps outlier?

LNF: Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy Tick the success criteria box on your worksheet

Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary · Final answer check

3 minutes

Plenary: Check your summary statistics

Verify your Step 1 and Step 3 answers against the table below before handing in your worksheet.

Location Min Q1 (4th) Median (8th) Q3 (12th) Max Range IQR Mean
Cwm Hafod 6 10 18 26 310 304 16 37
Trefelin 32 44 56 68 80 48 24 56
LNF: Interpreting data · DCF: Data and information literacy Claims: A = Misleading/False · B = True · C = True · D = True