Skills for Life: Ethical Choices
Ethical Choices is an Open Awards Skills for Life unit offered at 5 levels, Entry Level 1 to Level 2, each a separate 20 guided learning hour unit. Learners move from telling right from wrong actions to defining ethical principles, analysing viewpoints and justifying and evaluating a decision made with a structured process. The provider sets the tasks and the learner builds a portfolio. Literacy demand is medium: Entry levels use pictures, sorting and short spoken answers, while Levels 1 and 2 need defining, explaining, comparing, justifying and evaluating in speech or writing. There is no numeracy content.
- Awarding body
- Open Awards
- Level
- Entry Level 1 to Level 2
- Guided learning hours
- 20
- First taught
- September 2027
- Amount of literacy work
- Medium
- Amount of numeracy work
- Low
- Specification
- Open the specification
How this unit is assessed
- Entry Level 1 (CBM056): Three learning outcomes: identify a right and a wrong action, identify how someone might feel after each, and choose a right action from two options with a simple reason. Evidence can come from pointing, matching, sorting images and short verbal responses, or a real-life situation. 20 guided learning hours, 2 credits, Pass only when every criterion is met.
- Entry Level 2 (CBM057, printed as CMB057): Three learning outcomes: state what is meant by being fair and being honest, identify who is involved in a simple situation and how a choice affects at least two people, and choose an action in a scenario, give a reason and identify one result. Evidence can be real-life or simulated, through role play, card sorts and short verbal or written responses. 20 guided learning hours, 2 credits.
- Entry Level 3 (CBM058): Three learning outcomes: state what is meant by respect and responsibility, identify two viewpoints and describe how people may feel differently, and follow a three step process (for example Stop, Think, Choose) to make a choice and describe a consequence. 20 guided learning hours, 2 credits.
- Level 1 (CBM059): Three learning outcomes: outline at least 3 ethical principles and describe why they matter, describe how an ethical choice affects different people, and describe and apply a structured decision-making approach to a given scenario, then review it with at least one strength and one improvement. 20 guided learning hours, 2 credits.
- Level 2 (CBM060): Three learning outcomes and 10 criteria: define at least 3 ethical principles, explain and compare them, describe the features of a dilemma, analyse the viewpoints of at least 3 people or groups and explain consequences of 2 actions, then apply at least 2 principles, use a structured process, justify the decision, evaluate its impact on 3 groups and evaluate how their decision-making could improve. 20 guided learning hours, 2 credits.
The literacy and numeracy skills in this qualification
-
Stating and defining ethical ideas and principles
Entry Level 2 learners state what being fair and honest mean, Entry Level 3 learners state what respect and responsibility mean, Level 1 learners outline at least 3 principles and Level 2 learners define at least 3, such as utilitarianism or care ethics. This needs precise subject vocabulary and is required by the criteria.
Literacy: Clarity and vocabulary, Vocabulary, spelling, grammar
Getting pupils ready
- Year 7
- Pupils write a one sentence meaning for fair, honest and respect, each with an example from school life.
- Year 8
- Pupils make a glossary of 5 ethical words, such as responsibility and justice, and use each one correctly in a sentence.
- Year 9
- Pupils define 3 ethical principles, such as greatest good for the greatest number and duty, in their own words and give an example of each.
Show the specification wording and the LNF statements
Where it is in the specification: Level 2 (CBM060), AC 1.1 indicative content, page 22; Entry Level 2 to Level 1 criteria, pages 13 to 19
“Learners must define at least 3 ethical principles, such as:”
Progression step 3
I can express issues and ideas clearly using area of learning and experience/discipline-specific vocabulary and examples.
I can use varied, appropriate and precise vocabulary including area of learning and experience/discipline-specific words for different purposes.
Progression step 4
I have experienced a range of area of learning and experience/discipline-specific and general academic vocabulary, and can use them in my own communication.
I have experienced a range of area of learning and experience/discipline-specific and general academic vocabulary, and can use them in my own communication.
-
Describing and analysing different viewpoints
Entry Level 3 learners identify 2 viewpoints and describe how people may feel differently, Level 1 learners describe how a choice affects different people, and Level 2 learners analyse the viewpoints of at least 3 people or groups and explain consequences of 2 actions for each. This is required by the criteria.
Literacy: Listening to understand, Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context, Purpose
Getting pupils ready
- Year 7
- Pupils read a short story about two friends who want different things and write how each one feels and why.
- Year 8
- Pupils listen to three classmates role play a dilemma and record each character's view in a table before giving their own.
- Year 9
- Pupils write a paragraph analysing how a pupil, a parent and a teacher might each see a phone ban, showing empathy for all three.
Show the specification wording and the LNF statements
Where it is in the specification: Level 2 (CBM060), AC 2.2 indicative content, page 22; Entry Level 3 and Level 1 criteria, pages 15 and 18
“learners must analyse the viewpoints of at least three different people or groups involved”
Progression step 3
I can listen to others’ ideas/presentations, and understand that they may have a different perspective to my own, in order to respond appropriately.
I can write about my thoughts, feelings and opinions, showing empathy and respect.
Progression step 4
I can listen to gain different people's views and ideas on various subjects, using them to arrive at my own conclusions.
I can share, talk and write about my thoughts, feelings and opinions showing empathy and respect.
-
Justifying and evaluating a decision
Entry level learners give a simple reason for a choice. Level 1 learners review their decision with a strength and an improvement, and Level 2 learners justify the decision by referring to the process, factors and alternatives, then evaluate its effect on 3 groups and how their decision-making could improve. This is required by the criteria.
Literacy: Purpose, Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context, Questioning
Getting pupils ready
- Year 7
- Pupils finish the sentence "I chose this because..." for three dilemmas, giving a clear reason each time.
- Year 8
- Pupils write a short decision record listing the options they considered, the one they chose and one thing they would do differently.
- Year 9
- Pupils write a justified decision for a dilemma, naming the steps they followed and the alternative they rejected, then defend it against a classmate's challenge.
Show the specification wording and the LNF statements
Where it is in the specification: Level 2 (CBM060), AC 3.3 indicative content, page 23; Level 1, AC 3.3, page 19
“Justification must reference the process followed, the factors they identified in the process, any alternative decisions they considered.”
Progression step 3
I can share, talk and write about my thoughts, feelings and opinions using a range of techniques to show impact.
I can write a comprehensive account of a topic, theme or viewpoint.
Progression step 4
I can sustain a convincing point of view, anticipating and responding to other perspectives.
I can use summary, discussion of issues, detailed explanations and logic when covering a topic.
-
Discussing ethical scenarios in groups
Suggested assessment tasks at Entry Level 3 and Level 1 include scenario-based discussion, and providers need a teaching space where several group discussions can happen at once. Discussion is a suggested task type rather than a criterion.
Literacy: Collaborative talk, Listening as part of collaborative talk
Getting pupils ready
- Year 7
- Pupils stand on an agree to disagree line for a statement such as "It is fine to tell a white lie" and give one reason.
- Year 8
- Pupils discuss a dilemma in groups of four, each arguing a different option, and agree the fairest choice.
- Year 9
- Pupils hold a structured discussion on a workplace dilemma, responding to each other's points and reaching a group decision they can explain.
Show the specification wording and the LNF statements
Where it is in the specification: Assessment Approach, Level 1 task examples, page 9; Physical Resources, page 5
“Engage in scenario-based discussions.”
Progression step 3
I can explore challenging or contentious issues through a variety of authentic contexts, including sustaining a role.
I can listen in order to show agreement and disagreement in collaborative discussion and situations.
Progression step 4
I can use talk in a range of authentic contexts to explore challenging or contentious issues.
I can listen to and respond to others with questions, comments and suggestions in order to develop collaborative talk and reach compromise/consensus.
Good to know
- Each level is a separate 2 credit, 20 guided learning hour unit, CBM056 to CBM060: "Guided Learning Hours: 20" (Unit Content, pages 11 to 21; Qualification Guide, Qualification Units, page 18).
- Only one level counts in a qualification: "units with the same title at different levels are barred for completion within the same qualification" (Qualification Guide, Qualification Units, page 17).
- The provider writes the tasks: "This suite of units has been designed to be assessed through assessment tasks and activities designed by the provider", and pre-course verification must confirm tasks cover every criterion (Assessment Approach, page 6).
- There is no partial credit: "No partial award can be made if any assessment criteria is not met" (Assessment Approach, page 6).
- Evidence goes in a portfolio, digital or paper: "Wherever possible, e-portfolios are encouraged." Work is checked by internal quality assurance and then by Open Awards (Assessment Approach, page 6).
- Staff need training for sensitive topics, since "scenarios may include bullying, mental health, discrimination, consent and ethics" (Staffing Resources, page 5).
- The language load rises with the level, so providers must check learners can cope: "the provider must complete robust initial assessments" (Entry Requirements, page 5).
- Level 2 justification has fixed content: it "must reference the process followed, the factors they identified in the process, any alternative decisions they considered" (Level 2 indicative content, page 23).
- Numeracy is not listed: every level gives its cross-curricular skills as "Literacy and Digital" (Unit Content, pages 12 to 24).
- The Entry Level 2 unit code is printed "CMB057" (page 13), but the Qualification Guide lists it as CBM057, and Level 1 indicative content says "Leaner must give at least three" (page 19). The text also opens with the stray heading "Faith and Belief in the Community" left over from another unit's template.
- The unit specification says nothing about the use of AI or about referencing sources.
Links with other qualifications
Defining principles, explaining consequences and justifying a view build the argument and discussion skills of GCSE English Language, and the Level 2 work on utilitarianism, deontology and virtue ethics links closely with GCSE Religious Studies. The WJEC Skills Suite and Pearson both have an Ethical choices unit; the Open Awards unit asks for more extended reasoning at Level 2, with 10 criteria including comparing principles and evaluating the decision for 3 groups. Within the Open Awards suite it pairs with Equality, Diversity and Inclusion and Everyday Law.
Source: Open Awards Skills for Life Unit Specification, Ethical Choices, Entry Level 1 to Level 2 (units CBM056 to CBM060).