Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · Maths · Year 9
3 minutesReviewing a Pythagoras revision slideshow: 4 slides, 3 things to check
You have a worksheet and a stimulus sheet showing Ffion’s first draft of 4 revision slides on Pythagoras’ theorem, made for Year 8. Her teacher wants them reviewed before they go online. Today you check the maths, judge the design, proofread the writing, give feedback Ffion can act on, and redesign slide 3.
While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet, then read sections 1 and 2 of the stimulus sheet: the maths, and Mr Rowlands’ checklist.
Starter question: Which side of a right-angled triangle is the hypotenuse, and what is always true about its length?
Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key words · Maths · Year 9
2 minutesYour brief: is the maths right, does the design work, is the writing accurate?
A good reviewer checks 3 things: the maths, the design for the audience (Year 8 beginners on phones and the classroom board), and the writing. You will redo Ffion’s 2 examples, judge each slide against the checklist, find 17 text errors, write 3 comments, draw a better slide 3 and justify 3 changes.
Hypotenuse
The longest side of a right-angled triangle, opposite the right angle, called c. a² + b² = c².
Proofread
Reading text slowly to find and correct every error in spelling, punctuation, grammar and notation, such as a² rather than a2.
Audience and purpose
Who the slides are for and what they must do. Here: Year 8 beginners, revising on a phone, so short text, strong contrast and correct diagrams.
Slide 3 of 7 · Step 1: check the maths · Maths · Year 9
9 minutesStep 1: redo slides 3 and 4 correctly, then find the other maths mistakes
Use the correct method in section 1 of the stimulus. Part (a) is on the board: copy it, then do (b), (c) and (d). Show every step.
| Part | Working |
|---|---|
| (a) Redo slide 3: shorter sides 5 cm and 12 cm, find the hypotenuse | a² + b² = c². 5² + 12² = 25 + 144 = 169. c = √169 = 13 cm. Ffion added the sides without squaring them. |
| (b) Redo slide 4: hypotenuse 10 cm, one side 6 cm, find the other side | To find a shorter side, subtract. ? |
| (c) Without calculating, how could Ffion have known 11.66190379 cm was wrong? | ? |
| (d) 2 more mistakes on slide 2 (words and diagram), 1 in the last sentence of slide 4 | ? |
Slide 4 of 7 · Steps 2 and 3: judge the design, then proofread · Maths · Year 9
14 minutesStep 2 & Step 3: the biggest design problem per slide, then find 17 text errors
Step 2 (6 min): for each slide, give the number from Mr Rowlands’ checklist of its biggest design problem and say why it matters for a Year 8 pupil on a phone. Slide 1 is on the board. Then find 1 thing Ffion did well. Step 3 (8 min): circle all 17 spelling, punctuation, grammar and notation errors in the slide text on your worksheet with a coloured pen, write the correction above each, then rewrite the long last sentence of slide 4 as 2 or 3 correct sentences.
| Slide | Checklist number | Why it matters for this audience |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 (also 3 and 4) | Red writing on dark green has very little contrast, so it is hard to read on a small phone screen and impossible for many people with red-green colour blindness. 4 fonts look messy, and the pyramid does not help explain the maths. |
Proofreading model: slide 1 “Therom” → Theorem. That is error 1 of 17. Count as you go.
Slide 5 of 7 · Steps 4 and 5: feedback for Ffion, then redesign slide 3 · Maths · Year 9
14 minutesStep 4 & Step 5: write 3 comments, then draw a better slide 3
Step 4 (4 min): 3 comments as if added to the slides online, kind, specific and useful: 1 praise, 1 question, 1 suggestion. The praise row is on the board. Step 5 (10 min): draw your improved slide 3 in the box. It must have a short title, a correctly labelled right-angled triangle with the right-angle mark, the correct working with a² notation, the answer with its unit, and no more than 30 words. Note your colours and fonts beside it.
| Type | Slide | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Praise (what works and why) | 3 | Slide 3 is short and uses easy numbers (5 and 12 give a whole-number answer), which is perfect for beginners. |
| Question (to make her think) | ? | ? |
| Suggestion (one clear change) | ? | ? |
Slide 6 of 7 · Step 6: justify, then self and partner check · Maths · Year 9
5 minutesStep 6: justify 3 changes with “because”, then check against the success criteria
Explain 3 changes you made to slide 3 and why each makes it better for Year 8 pupils revising on a phone. Use the word “because” in each. Then swap with your partner and tick each success criterion their work meets.
- I can use Pythagoras’ theorem to check a worked example, and spot an answer that cannot be right.
- I can judge a digital resource against its audience and purpose and explain each problem.
- I can proofread for spelling, punctuation, grammar and notation, and correct every error I find.
- I can give feedback that is kind, specific and useful.
- I can redesign a slide and justify each change for the audience.
Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary review · Maths · Year 9
3 minutesRound the room, then quick-check answers before handing in
Everyone names 1 of the 17 text errors and its correction, nobody repeats one. Then check these answers.
| Question | Correct answer |
|---|---|
| What should slide 3 and slide 4 give as their answers? | Slide 3: 13 cm (25 + 144 = 169, √169 = 13). Slide 4: 8 cm (100 − 36 = 64, √64 = 8). |
| How could Ffion have known 11.66 cm was wrong without calculating? | The hypotenuse is always the longest side, and 11.66 cm is longer than the 10 cm hypotenuse. |
| What is the biggest design problem on slide 1, and why? | Contrast (checklist point 2): red on dark green is hard to read on a phone and impossible for many colour-blind pupils. |