Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · History · Year 9
5 minutesVerifying Historical Photographs and Captions from the South Wales Coalfield
Social media accounts often repost historic Welsh photographs with wrong dates, cropped watermarks or unlabelled AI colourisation. Today you will act as digital archivists and verify four viral posts against official coalfield catalogue cards.
While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet, then compare Post A and Archive Card 1 on the stimulus sheet.
Starter question: Give two reasons why Post A (“Rare original colour photo of Tonypandy colliers cheering a pay rise in 1910”) misleads its readers.
Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key terms · History · Year 9
5 minutesProvenance, Copyright and Creative Commons
Historians check a source’s provenance (who created it, when, and where it is kept) before trusting it. Digital publishers must also obey copyright law and Creative Commons licence codes.
| Code or term | Rule to remember |
|---|---|
| Provenance | The documented origin of a source: photographer, date, archive collection and reference code. |
| 70-year rule | UK copyright normally lasts for the creator’s life plus 70 years after the year they died. |
| BY / NC / ND / SA | BY = credit creator · NC = non-commercial · ND = no cropping or edits · SA = share under same licence. |
Slide 3 of 7 · Step 1: Spot the historical and visual errors · History · Year 9
10 minutesStep 1: Audit Posts A to D Against the Archive Cards
Compare each viral post in Section 1 of the stimulus sheet with its matching archive card in Section 2. Fill in the Step 1 table on your worksheet.
Worked first row (Post A · Ref CWM-1910-042):
True date and event: November 1910, Cambrian Combine Lockout in Tonypandy.
What the caption or image gets wrong: Presented as an original colour photo when it is an AI-colourised black-and-white negative; claims colliers are cheering a pay rise when they are queuing for soup tickets.
Slide 4 of 7 · Step 2: Copyright duration and licence breaches · History · Year 9
10 minutesStep 2: Check Copyright Dates and Licence Rules
Use the 70-year copyright rule and the Creative Commons codes on the stimulus sheet to complete Step 2.
70-Year Rule Formula
Year photographer died + 70 = end of UK copyright year.
Example (Arthur Lewis): 1938 + 70 = 2008 (now Public Domain).
Which Rule Was Broken?
Post B cropped the watermark (→ breaks BY and ND).
Post C sold mugs for £14.99 (→ breaks NC and BY).
Slide 5 of 7 · Step 3: Write accurate museum captions · History · Year 9
12 minutesStep 3: Rewrite Two Captions Using TASL
Choose two photographs from the archive cards and write a complete museum display caption for each in Step 3. Every caption needs historical context plus a four-part TASL attribution line.
Model TASL structure:
Context: In November 1910, striking coal miners queued outside Tonypandy Central Hall for soup tickets during the Cambrian Combine Lockout.
Attribution: Title: Striking miners queuing for soup tickets (Ref: CWM-1910-042) · Author: Arthur Lewis · Source: Glamorgan Coalfield Collection · Licence: Public Domain (original monochrome glass-plate negative; any colourisation must be stated).
Slide 6 of 7 · Step 4: Historian’s judgement and self-check · History · Year 9
5 minutesStep 4: Why Provenance and Licensing Matter
In Step 4, write a short paragraph explaining why unverified colourisation and cropped watermarks damage historical understanding. Then tick the success criteria box on your worksheet.
- Did you name the archive reference codes (such as CWM-1921-118)?
- Did you explain the difference between an original source and a digital alteration?
- Did you explain why BY and ND protect both creators and historians?
Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary quick check · History · Year 9
3 minutesPlenary Quick Check Before Hand-In
Check your key answers before passing your worksheet to the front:
| Question | Correct answer |
|---|---|
| Why could Post B not show 9-year-old boys underground in 1926? | The photo was taken on 14 May 1921 at the surface lamp room, and the Coal Mines Act 1911 barred under-14s from underground work. |
| Which licence terms did Post B break by cropping the strip? | CC BY-NC-ND 4.0: broke BY (removed credit) and ND (cropped image). |
| When does copyright expire on Gareth Thomas’s 1936 photo? | 31 December 2062 (died 1992 + 70 years). |